The plenum of the Czech Constitutional Court, meaning the assembly of all its judges, has ruled that if an offender intentionally causes non-material harm to a victim, a court may not reduce the compensation on the grounds that paying it would ruin the offender. The case involved children who were victims of serious sexual crimes.
The Regional Court in Ústí nad Labem and the High Court in Prague awarded the victims compensation for non-material harm, but cut it in view of the offender’s financial situation so that the payment would not have “liquidating” effects. In total, the victims were to receive two million crowns.
The victims turned to the Constitutional Court. The three-judge panel that heard the case concluded that it was time to change the current practice and referred the dispute to all of the court’s judges. They sided with the victims.
“If a defendant causes non-material harm in connection with a crime, criminal courts must assess the form of fault with respect to that harm. If they conclude that the harm was caused intentionally, the amount of compensation cannot be reduced by citing the liquidating impact on the offender’s assets. The opposite approach violates the injured party’s right to judicial protection,” said Judge Rapporteur Kateřina Ronovská.
The judges added that although this position was adopted primarily with regard to interference with a person’s mental and physical integrity, it also applies to other interference with the personal sphere and to compensation for non-material harm caused in that way.
The ruling does not, however, mean that offenders must sink into complete destitution. Enforcement and bankruptcy law prevent that: even when large sums are being recovered, the debtor keeps enough funds for a dignified life and does not fall into absolute material need.
Around Prague, based on reporting by novinky.cz