Crime By

Czech Constitutional Court: crime victims’ compensation can’t be cut

Constitutional Court: crime victims get full compensation, even if it ruins the offender

The plenum of the Czech Constitutional Court, meaning the assembly of all its judges, has ruled that if an offender intentionally causes non-material harm to a victim, a court may not reduce the compensation on the grounds that paying it would ruin the offender. The case involved children who were victims of serious sexual crimes.

The Regional Court in Ústí nad Labem and the High Court in Prague awarded the victims compensation for non-material harm, but cut it in view of the offender’s financial situation so that the payment would not have “liquidating” effects. In total, the victims were to receive two million crowns.

How the case reached the plenum

The victims turned to the Constitutional Court. The three-judge panel that heard the case concluded that it was time to change the current practice and referred the dispute to all of the court’s judges. They sided with the victims.

“If a defendant causes non-material harm in connection with a crime, criminal courts must assess the form of fault with respect to that harm. If they conclude that the harm was caused intentionally, the amount of compensation cannot be reduced by citing the liquidating impact on the offender’s assets. The opposite approach violates the injured party’s right to judicial protection,” said Judge Rapporteur Kateřina Ronovská.

The judges added that although this position was adopted primarily with regard to interference with a person’s mental and physical integrity, it also applies to other interference with the personal sphere and to compensation for non-material harm caused in that way.

No absolute poverty

The ruling does not, however, mean that offenders must sink into complete destitution. Enforcement and bankruptcy law prevent that: even when large sums are being recovered, the debtor keeps enough funds for a dignified life and does not fall into absolute material need.

Around Prague, based on reporting by novinky.cz

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Kash Patel Skips House Hearing: How the Dispute Built Since July
FBI Director Kash Patel did not appear at the House Homeland Security Committee's annual worldwide threats hearing on Wednesday, drawing criticism from lawmakers in both parties. The Independent repor
Robert Garcia Orders Trump Allies to Save Records Ahead of House Probes
Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, sent letters Wednesday telling a dozen or more associates of President Donald Trump to preserve their records before Democrats ta
Iran Targets Kuwait and Bahrain After U.S. Strike on Missile Site
Iran's army said its drones targeted U.S. military assets at Ali Al Salem Air Base in Kuwait, and Bahrain reported intercepting multiple Iranian aerial attacks, as a months-long confrontation in the G
Ransomware Gang Claims Nvidia Hack and Starts a 10-Day Countdown, but Shows No Proof
The Gentlemen, one of the most active ransomware groups of the past year, has added Nvidia to its dark web leak site and started a countdown to publish what it says is the chipmaker's data. The group
What Florida's Coastal Flooding Means for Residents and Thanksgiving Travelers
Floodwater closed roads, stranded vehicles and entered homes in southeast Florida on Tuesday night, CNN reported, as the first stretch of a multiday flood threat began along the state's Atlantic coast
Hakeem Jeffries Wins House Democrats' Nomination for Speaker, 251-11
House Democrats on Wednesday nominated Rep. Hakeem Jeffries of New York to be speaker of the House, a step that puts him on track to become the first Black speaker in U.S. history when the new Congres

Related news

Reporter Jakub Mikel spent two months under a false name in the Czech cell of the neo-Nazi organization Active Club, headquartered in Prague’s Libeň district. According to his investigation, the group recruits teenagers through Telegram, an
The Regional Court in Brno has confirmed a three-year suspended prison sentence with a five-year probation period for a 37-year-old man who shot a fleeing thief in the back. Prosecutors had classed the act as attempted murder, which carries
Police in the US have arrested a father who left his six-year-old daughter alone in a queue outside a Target shopping centre around 1 a.m. to get Pokémon cards. The man was charged with child neglect; the girl was not hurt. His trial is set
In Brno, police have detained a man who, under the influence of drugs, got into a flat from the terrace where two children were home. The older girl tried to keep him out and was hurt by shards of glass, police spokesman Petr Vala said.A pa
An unknown driver hit a rare hunting dog on the road between Slušovice and Lípa at around 11:40 a.m. on Saturday, Nov. 14, and drove away from the scene. The dog, a Briquet Griffon Vendéen, ran onto the road during a hunt and died of its in
Traffic police in the Vyškov district have detained a driver who was banned from driving, rammed a patrol car and tried to get away. The man is suspected of violence against a public official and of obstructing an official decision, and fac
Near Tábor in South Bohemia, a drunk driver crashed his Volkswagen into a concrete pole. Three men aged 30 to 40 suffered serious injuries and were taken to hospitals in České Budějovice.According to South Bohemian police spokeswoman Lenka
On Thursday afternoon, a 60-year-old man got behind the wheel with 2.54 per mille of alcohol in his blood and never made it home: according to Zlín police, he collided with two parked cars and a stone fence post. The damage is preliminarily
Police in the Vyškov area of South Moravia have detained a driver who is banned from driving: he tried to escape a patrol first by car and then on foot. South Moravia police spokesman David Chaloupka said the man now faces criminal prosecut
Unknown people are laying bait containing rodent poison in the municipality of Kamenný Újezd in the České Budějovice area, and it is dangerous for dogs and cats. Local authorities have warned animal owners, including on social media.The rod
A court has found a prison guard guilty for the third time of causing grievous bodily harm and abuse of power as a public official. For beating an inmate who had to have his spleen removed because of his injuries, he received a three-year s
Maxa, a provocative blogger from Plzeň known for scandalous behavior on social media, has posted a profane TikTok video challenging Judge Vladimír Žák to a cage fight. Maxa is due to serve 14 months in a high-security prison, but the verdic