Canada's federal competition watchdog is moving ahead with an investigation into whether the clothing chains Gap and Old Navy are making false or misleading claims in their advertising, CBC News reported. The probe focuses on two practices shoppers see every day: the "regular" prices shown next to sale items, and the pop-up messages that urge people to buy quickly.
For Canadian shoppers, the investigation is about whether a discount is really a discount, and whether a warning that stock is running low reflects reality.
The Competition Bureau, the federal agency that enforces Canada's competition and marketing rules, has been granted a court order for information. According to the bureau, the material will help it determine whether Gap and Old Navy are giving customers genuine regular prices when they advertise items as being on sale.
The question matters because a sale price only means something if the regular price it is compared with is real. If a regular price is inflated, a bargain can look bigger than it is. The bureau is trying to establish whether that is happening at the two retailers.
The investigation also covers what the bureau calls urgency cues. These are messages such as "Selling Fast" or "Only a Few Left" that appear on the retailers' websites while consumers are browsing.
In an email to CBC News, the bureau made clear that using such claims is not prohibited. It said, however, that they can raise concerns under the Competition Act, the law the bureau enforces, if they create a false or misleading impression for potential shoppers about how popular a product is or how many are available.
A bureau spokesperson told CBC that the growing online marketplace gives fake urgency cues an easy place to spread. The spokesperson said it is important that consumers shop wisely and that businesses do not use pressure tactics that mislead them.
Old Navy and Gap are both owned by Gap Inc. The two brands operate online and through bricks-and-mortar stores across the country, nationally. CBC News said it had asked Gap Inc. for comment on the investigation.
The bureau says it took action after a surge in complaints last year about allegedly inflated regular prices. At that time, it published a warning to remind businesses of their obligations under the Competition Act. That reminder was aimed at businesses in general rather than at any single company.
The investigation is ongoing, and the bureau says it has not yet found any instances of wrongdoing. Having a court order for information means the bureau is gathering material that it expects to help it assess the pricing and the urgency messages, but the existence of an inquiry is not a finding against either retailer.
For now, the practical takeaway for shoppers is limited to what the bureau itself has said: it is examining whether sale prices at the two chains are measured against genuine regular prices, and whether online messages about popularity and availability give an accurate picture. The bureau has also said that such messages are not banned outright, and that its concern is whether they mislead.
Around Prague, based on reporting by CBC News