Science & Space By

BMI Alone Missed Obesity in Up to 8.6 Percent of People in a Study of 844,108 Adults

Body-mass index may misclassify obesity for a meaningful share of people, according to a new international study published in Nature. ScienceAlert reported that the researchers compared BMI with a broader definition of obesity proposed by experts in 2025 and concluded that millions of people worldwide could be misdiagnosed.

The new framework also separates obesity that is already damaging the body from obesity that has not yet caused harm, a distinction the study linked to very different risks of dying.

The key numbers

What BMI measures, and what the new framework adds

BMI divides a person’s weight by their height squared. ScienceAlert noted that it has long been seen as too approximate. The 2025 framework takes in other measurements, including waist circumference, waist-to-height ratio and body fat scans. It also looks for signs of organ damage or physical impairment that affects everyday activities.

Under the framework, clinical obesity is a condition in which excess fat is damaging internal systems and organs. Preclinical obesity means a person has excess weight that has not yet begun to harm how the body works.

Why it matters for patients and treatment

The difference showed up clearly in outcomes. Clinical obesity was associated with a 69 percent higher risk of dying over follow-up periods of more than a decade, versus 19 percent for preclinical obesity. ScienceAlert noted that traditional diagnosis would not flag that gap.

Rubino said most people with preclinical obesity, though not all, remained free of clinical obesity for a decade. He said preclinical obesity should be neither treated automatically as active disease nor dismissed as harmless. Some people may need preventive treatment, he said, but its intensity should match their individual risk.

The report said researchers hope that, if doctors and health care professionals adopt the proposals more widely, treatments such as GLP-1 weight loss drugs can go to people who really need them, rather than to everyone classified as obese under BMI rules.

Epidemiologist An Pan of Huazhong University of Science and Technology in China said the differences in prognosis were consistent across countries and ethnic groups. In his view, that supports adopting the new framework globally to improve obesity care and policy.

What happens next

The team plans further studies on how to apply the new criteria effectively and on refining the diagnostic techniques to make them more accurate. Future research could also examine how treatments affect the health of people with clinical and preclinical obesity.

The findings could help research in other areas of health, too, such as working out whether heart disease was brought on by obesity or by something else. Rubino said that getting the scope of care right, whether treating existing disease or reducing risk, matters both for the billion-plus people affected and for health care systems.

Around Prague, based on reporting by ScienceAlert

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More science news

Trump’s Asia Trip Ends With First Summit Among Him, Xi and Putin
President Donald Trump heads to Asia this week for a trip that will end with an unprecedented three-way summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, according to The
Sponge-on-a-String Test for Esophageal Cancer Risk Recommended for NHS Use
Thousands of people in England who are at higher risk of esophageal cancer could soon be offered a seven-minute test on the National Health Service that involves swallowing a small capsule on a string
Why Chess AI Keeps the Pressure On Late in Games While Humans Ease Off
Researchers who analyzed online chess games say strong engines keep the board in a state of high strategic tension deep into a game, while human players tend to simplify their positions as the game go
Mechanical Arms Snag a 407-Foot Starship Out of the Sky After Orbit
SpaceX caught its Starship upper stage with the giant mechanical arms of its launch tower on Saturday, after the vehicle returned from a full orbital flight. La Voce di New York reported that it was t
Artificial Muscles Let a Robot Hand Play Piano and Robot Eyes Hold a Gaze
Engineers at the University of Pennsylvania have built an artificial muscle that can make fine, steady movements, the kind needed to move a finger or hold an eye in place. Popular Science reported tha
Haaland Points to Long-Term Contract as Man City Appeal Heads Toward December Hearing
Manchester City striker Erling Haaland has played down talk that an ongoing appeals process could affect his future at the club. He said he signed a long-term contract in 2024, according to the London

Related news

President Donald Trump heads to Asia this week for a trip that will end with an unprecedented three-way summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, according to The New York Times, The Guardian and the Hon
Thousands of people in England who are at higher risk of esophageal cancer could soon be offered a seven-minute test on the National Health Service that involves swallowing a small capsule on a string. The National Institute for Health and
Researchers who analyzed online chess games say strong engines keep the board in a state of high strategic tension deep into a game, while human players tend to simplify their positions as the game goes on. Scientific American reported on t
SpaceX caught its Starship upper stage with the giant mechanical arms of its launch tower on Saturday, after the vehicle returned from a full orbital flight. La Voce di New York reported that it was the first time a rocket's upper stage has
Engineers at the University of Pennsylvania have built an artificial muscle that can make fine, steady movements, the kind needed to move a finger or hold an eye in place. Popular Science reported that the team tested it on a robotic hand t
Manchester City striker Erling Haaland has played down talk that an ongoing appeals process could affect his future at the club. He said he signed a long-term contract in 2024, according to the London Evening Standard. The newspaper reporte
Sour-sensing cells in the taste bud release the chemical serotonin, which quiets neighboring cells that detect other tastes, according to a new study in mice, Scientific American reported. The finding suggests that taste buds do more than r
For the first time, astronomers have followed a giant exoplanet as it gradually dropped out of view from Earth. The planet, TOI-2535b, had vanished by March 2026, according to ScienceAlert, which reported on a paper in The Astrophysical Jou
The SS Central America, a wooden steamship that sank in a hurricane off South Carolina in 1857, is now remembered less for the 425 people who died than for its gold and the courtroom fights that followed its discovery, Popular Science repor
NASA's Voyager 1 is set to reach a distance of one light-day from Earth on Wednesday, NPR reported. The spacecraft is already the farthest anything humans have launched into space, and the agency is marking the milestone with a public event
United Launch Alliance's Vulcan rocket failed to reach orbit Sunday, Nov. 15, losing all 40 Amazon Leo internet satellites it was carrying. The company said an anomaly struck about 10 minutes after liftoff from Cape Canaveral Space Force St
NASA's Voyager 1, already the most distant human-made object, reaches a new marker on Nov. 18: it will be one light-day from Earth, so far away that light needs 24 hours to cross the gap, according to Live Science. NASA says the spacecraft