U.S. By

Appeals Court Presses DOJ on Bid to Set Aside 20,000 California Mail Ballots

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on Sunday raised doubts about the Trump administration's emergency request to make California set aside roughly 20,000 mail ballots linked to people the Justice Department suspects are noncitizens, Fox News reported. The hearing, which ran nearly two hours, came as voting for the midterm elections is already well underway in the state.

The judges questioned both the government's legal arguments and whether the appeals court has the authority to step in at this stage, according to Fox News. Judge Mark Bennett said the panel would try to rule as quickly as possible.

The numbers behind the dispute

What the judges asked

Bennett, appointed by President Donald Trump, asked whether the injunction the administration wants could be squared with the Constitution's Elections Clause, which gives state legislatures authority over the times, places and manner of congressional elections, subject to regulation by Congress. He told Justice Department attorney Matthew Donnelly that the request appeared to conflict with a law the California legislature had adopted under that clause, and asked how the court could grant it.

Judge Gabriel Sanchez, appointed by President Joe Biden, asked why the appeals court should get involved when the district court has not ruled and its own hearing is still ahead. Judge Patrick Bumatay, another Trump appointee, put more emphasis on the government's concerns about possible voting by noncitizens and questioned how California handles challenges involving suspected ineligible voters, Fox News reported.

What each side argues

The Justice Department asked the appeals court to act after Carter did not rule by a deadline the department had requested. It argued that hundreds of thousands of California ballots could be tabulated each day while the case is unresolved, and said every day without a ruling risks letting more ballots be processed before the citizenship question is settled. Before the hearing, the administration accused California of a history of mishandling its voter rolls.

California says the appeals court should wait for the lower court. The state also disputes the federal data and says it has strong safeguards against noncitizen voting. In a filing over the weekend, it argued that the federal theory would “turn the Constitution on its head,” and that Washington has no power over election administration in the states unless Congress passes a law on the time, place or manner of elections.

Los Angeles County officials have said a preliminary review of part of the federal list found apparent discrepancies, including people who were born in the United States or were not registered to vote.

Why it matters for California voters

The case bears directly on how ballots already in the mail are handled. If the court ordered the roughly 20,000 ballots set aside, they would be held back from normal processing while eligibility is checked. If the court declines, they would be processed with the rest of the vote as the state's count continues. California's position is that its existing safeguards already keep ineligible people from voting, and the county's early review of the federal list points to errors in that data, according to the officials quoted by Fox News.

The timing adds pressure. With more than 3 million ballots already cast and the count moving each day, both sides say speed matters, though they disagree about which court should act and when.

What happens next

The Ninth Circuit panel has not issued a ruling. Carter is scheduled to hold his own hearing on the Justice Department's request on Tuesday.

Around Prague, based on reporting by Fox News

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Trump Warns Iran Over Reported Plot Against Administration Officials: What We Know
President Donald Trump warned Iran on Monday that it would face retaliation on an unprecedented scale if it attacked Washington, D.C. He was responding to a CNN report, relayed by Fox News, that Iran
What GTA 6's Record Pre-Orders Could Mean for Fortnite, Roblox and Rival Games
Grand Theft Auto 6 has racked up an estimated $1.45 billion in pre-order revenue before its release, according to the market research firm Sensor Tower, as reported by ABP Live. WN Hub, citing the sam
What We Know About the Router Behind the FAA's Nationwide Ground Stop
A newly installed router is at the center of the investigation into the Federal Aviation Administration's nationwide ground stop last Friday, Axios reported. The failure exposed weaknesses in the FAA'
What We Know About the ICE Arrest of a Pregnant U.S. Citizen in Modesto
What happened in Modesto? Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents pepper-sprayed a pregnant U.S. citizen and threw her to the ground during a protest outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto,
Hillary Clinton Names Canada's Carney as Possible 'Leader of the Free World'
Hillary Clinton said in an interview that aired Sunday that if anyone fits the description of "leader of the free world" today, it may be Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, Fox News reported. The re
Ro Khanna Wants $1,700 Checks for Families Hit by Iran War Costs
Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., on Monday called for a $1,700 refund check to go to every American family, saying the money would offset higher prices linked to the war in Iran, Fox News reported. He urged

Related news

President Donald Trump warned Iran on Monday that it would face retaliation on an unprecedented scale if it attacked Washington, D.C. He was responding to a CNN report, relayed by Fox News, that Iran is weighing an attempt to kill senior ad
Grand Theft Auto 6 has racked up an estimated $1.45 billion in pre-order revenue before its release, according to the market research firm Sensor Tower, as reported by ABP Live. WN Hub, citing the same firm, put the figure at more than $1.4
A newly installed router is at the center of the investigation into the Federal Aviation Administration's nationwide ground stop last Friday, Axios reported. The failure exposed weaknesses in the FAA's aging telecommunications network and r
What happened in Modesto? Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents pepper-sprayed a pregnant U.S. citizen and threw her to the ground during a protest outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto, California, on Sunday, according to her
Hillary Clinton said in an interview that aired Sunday that if anyone fits the description of "leader of the free world" today, it may be Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, Fox News reported. The remark drew sharp responses from Trump adm
Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., on Monday called for a $1,700 refund check to go to every American family, saying the money would offset higher prices linked to the war in Iran, Fox News reported. He urged the House and Senate to pass the payment
The Commerce Department on Monday tightened export rules on top-tier American AI chips, requiring special licenses for data centers in five countries and for overseas customers that serve Chinese and other restricted companies, NBC News rep
Medline is recalling all of its Medline Brand beds, rails, mattresses and accessories in the United States because of a potential fire hazard and entrapment risk, according to a company announcement posted by the U.S. Food and Drug Administ
Authorities in Peoria, Illinois, are questioning a person of interest after an explosive device was found Friday at the BioUrja Renewables ethanol plant, according to Fox News, ABC News and the Guardian. No injuries were reported, and offic
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday that the NYPD's Strategic Response Group, known as the SRG, will be disbanded and that the city will move to a civilian-led approach to policing protests, Fox News and The Guardian reporte
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge to Maryland laws that bar firearms in sensitive places such as schools, parks and government buildings. The decision leaves in place a lower court ruling that upheld the restrictions,
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up the Trump administration's appeal over research grants it canceled for University of California scholars, according to NBC News and CBS News. The move leaves in place lower court rulings that