Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas has blocked President Donald Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Justice Department official, to a federal district court seat in the Dallas area, CBS News reported. Cornyn said he declined to return a blue slip for Gaiser, which effectively stalls the nomination in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
“I think his nomination is no longer viable,” Cornyn told CBS on Capitol Hill. Gaiser had been expected to have a confirmation hearing Wednesday, but he was not among the seven judicial candidates who testified before the committee.
Cornyn said Gaiser is not a Texan, has no trial experience, and that the White House tried to rush the Senate and did not allow time for the review needed for lifetime appointments. At an event Tuesday, he said there was no consultation and that the Senate is not supposed to be a rubber stamp. He said he has offered an alternative and is waiting to see whether the White House accepts it.
CBS noted that Gaiser does not live in Texas. His only apparent tie to the state is a one-year clerkship in Houston for a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit. He is a native of Ohio, served as its solicitor general and lived there until joining the Trump administration last year as head of the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel.
The blue-slip process is meant to encourage consultation between the White House and the two senators from a nominee’s home state. Here those senators are Cornyn and Cruz, both Republicans. After the president picks a candidate, each home-state senator receives a slip of paper showing approval or opposition. A senator can also withhold it, which is considered a sign of disapproval.
A district court nominee can get a Judiciary Committee hearing only if both home-state senators return positive slips. Trump has pushed Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley, an Iowa Republican, to eliminate the policy, but Grassley has kept the tradition for district court and U.S. attorney nominations, CBS reported.
In his Justice Department role, Gaiser has drawn criticism for legal opinions he issued that advise the president and federal agencies and are binding on the executive branch, CBS said. He wrote an opinion finding that the Presidential Records Act, which requires presidents to preserve certain documents and turn them over to the National Archives, is unconstitutional. Another opinion concluded that Trump’s outside advisers are protected from future congressional and legal investigations, with presidential communications with private outsiders generally covered by executive privilege.
The lame-duck session of Congress has begun after the midterms, and the Judiciary Committee is working to confirm the rest of Trump’s judicial nominees before the new Congress starts in January and control of the Senate changes hands, according to CBS. Cornyn’s decision means a Dallas-area seat on the Northern District of Texas court is still unfilled for now, and the White House has not said how it will respond.
Around Prague, based on reporting by CBS News