Lindsay Clancy will be tried a second time on charges that she killed her three children in 2023. Judge William Sullivan announced Monday that the retrial will begin March 29, according to NBC News and ABC News. The BBC gave the year as 2027.
The date follows a mistrial in September, when a jury could not reach a verdict. Prosecutors have not said publicly which charges they will pursue, though the defense says it expects the first-degree murder counts to return.
Clancy and her lawyers attended a status hearing to schedule the new trial, NBC News reported. The final pretrial hearing is set for March 18, which leaves both sides four months to prepare. ABC News reported that most of the session was spent arguing over a start date, with prosecutors citing several scheduling conflicts for the spring.
ABC also reported that Sullivan told lawyers earlier this month he wanted a March trial in part because he is nearing the mandatory judicial retirement age in Massachusetts later this year. The hearing grew tense briefly after a remark by defense attorney Kevin Reddington about the Ides of March drew a sharp response from prosecutor Jennifer Sprague.
Clancy is accused of strangling her three children with exercise bands on the night of Jan. 24, 2023, then jumping from a bedroom window, NBC reported. The fall left her paralyzed. She faced three counts of first-degree murder in the first trial. The BBC reported that she is now held in a state-run psychiatric hospital and medical facility in Massachusetts.
Her lawyers argue that Clancy was in the grip of postpartum psychosis and did not understand what she was doing. The BBC reported that the defense does not dispute that she killed the children. According to ABC, eleven jurors in the first trial favored acquittal by reason of insanity, while one holdout blocked a verdict.
The defense also argued that Sullivan should not have declared a mistrial without questioning that juror, NBC reported. Sullivan rejected a motion to dismiss the charges last week. Defense lawyers told ABC they plan to appeal but that the appeal will not delay the retrial. Reddington said he wants a spring trial and does not want Clancy to remain incarcerated for years.
Reddington said Sprague's comment that the case requires a jury was an indirect sign that prosecutors will retry the first-degree murder counts, since lesser charges could lead to a bench trial.
Prosecutors have said the killings were planned in advance and that Clancy was not in a state of psychosis, NBC reported. In court Monday, Sprague said the Plymouth County District Attorney's Office would need a jury, but she did not name the charges. She said the case would be a retrial and that its shape would depend on rulings still pending.
Prosecutors had other options after the ruling, NBC noted, including reduced charges, a bench trial, a plea deal or dropping the case. The BBC reported that the district attorney has not formally said he will proceed on first-degree murder, and that second-degree murder, which involves malice or extreme recklessness without planning, remains possible.
Prosecutors argued that a mistrial should be judged on what the court knew when it acted, not on later events or media accounts, according to NBC. They also lost a bid to limit lawyers from discussing the case publicly.
Sullivan wrote that the jury's deadlock created a manifest necessity for a mistrial, so a retrial does not violate Clancy's double jeopardy protection, ABC reported. In practice, the case goes back to a new jury and both sides must argue it again. NBC said it is unclear whether either side will change its arguments.
NBC also reported that Sullivan denied a defense request to question the holdout juror, Michael Desronvil, and to examine court records about his service. Desronvil has said he feels harassed since the trial ended and that he had no doubts.
The final pretrial hearing is March 18, and the retrial is set to start March 29. The defense appeal of the double jeopardy ruling is expected to go forward alongside those preparations. Prosecutors have said they will decide how to proceed after pending decisions come in.
Around Prague, based on reporting by NBC News, ABC News, BBC News