White House Tells Incoming Oversight Chair Probes Could Be Criminal

The White House has sent a pointed warning to the Democrat who will lead the House Oversight Committee, saying that investigations of the Trump administration must stay within constitutional limits. White House counsel Will Scharf wrote to Rep. Robert Garcia, D-Calif., that threats meant to scare executive branch officials could amount to "blatant criminality," according to CNN, which obtained the letter.

The letter is dated Nov. 9, a Monday. It lands before Democrats take over the House in January and signals a combative opening to what both sides expect to be a fight over subpoenas and oversight.

What the White House letter says

Scharf wrote that the administration "will not be extorted" and will not be cowed by legal process driven by animus, pettiness, hatred or any other unlawful motive, according to a copy cited by the New York Post. He said congressional investigations must serve a legitimate legislative purpose and cannot be used to exercise criminal prosecution powers that belong to the executive and judicial branches.

He argued that threats aimed at discouraging people from public service, or legal process meant only to instill fear, may cross into criminal conduct. He added that issuing unlawful subpoenas to deprive citizens of their rights may warrant further investigation.

Scharf cited Democrats' own statements as evidence. He wrote that some have compared their plans for subpoenas to handing out candy and Mardi Gras beads, and he pointed to the imagery of a campaign Garcia launched that featured a courtroom gavel. In his view, those statements make clear that coming investigations would be used to harass rather than to advance a legislative goal.

Bloomberg reported that the letter suggests Trump's team may take a hostile stance toward Democratic probes, potentially relying on untested legal arguments. The New York Post described it as a sign of the aggressive defense the White House is expected to mount under new Chief of Staff Stephen Miller.

How Garcia and Democrats respond

Garcia has promised an aggressive approach to oversight. On CNN's "State of the Union" over the weekend, he told Dana Bash that the days of Democrats not fighting back are over and that the party has to be in the fight.

He also accused Attorney General Todd Blanche of threatening committee members with investigations to keep them from doing oversight. "We're not going to be intimidated," Garcia said, adding that the administration can come after Democrats however it wants.

CNN reported that President Donald Trump has pushed his administration to investigate Democrats who are investigating him. Punchbowl's Jake Sherman said the White House warning is unlikely to deter Democrats, noting that Congress has ample precedent to investigate nearly anything it chooses, according to KFBK.

Where the two positions differ

• Purpose of probes: The White House says Democratic investigations will be about harassment. Democrats describe their planned work as oversight.
• Legal limits: Scharf stresses that Congress may investigate only for legislative purposes. Sherman said Congress has broad precedent to investigate.
• Who is threatening whom: The White House says Democrats are making abusive threats against officials. Garcia says the attorney general is threatening committee members.

Why it matters for the coming Congress

The exchange previews how oversight could work once Democrats control the House. According to the New York Post, Democrats have threatened a wave of subpoenas aimed at administration officials and the first family, and some incoming lawmakers have hinted that charges could follow. The letter signals that the White House may contest such subpoenas on constitutional grounds, which could determine what information Congress is able to obtain and how quickly.

For the public, the practical stakes are about access to information on how the government is run and about how far each branch can go in using its powers against the other. Neither side has yet issued a subpoena covered by the letter, and the legal arguments have not been tested in court in this context, according to Bloomberg's description of them as untested.

What comes next

Democrats formally take over the House in January. Garcia is expected to chair the Oversight Committee at that point, and the first subpoenas and the administration's response to them will show whether the letter's warnings become a legal confrontation.

Read next
Secret Service Arrests Man With Three Guns Near White House, DHS Says
FBI Investigates Suspicious Letters Sent to Senators and State Election Offices
U.S. Prosecutors Add Torture Conspiracy Charge Against Maduro and His Wife

Around Prague, based on reporting by Mezha.net, KFBK, Sean Hannity

Cover photo: U.S. House of Representatives / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)