U.S. By

Why the White House Dropped Heidi Overton's FDA Nomination: What We Know

The White House has dropped Dr. Heidi Overton's nomination to lead the Food and Drug Administration, a White House official confirmed Tuesday, according to NBC News and CNN. The Senate health committee had been due to vote on her Wednesday. Axios was first to report the decision.

What happened?

CBS News reported earlier Tuesday that Overton was struggling to win enough Republican votes on the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee and that none of the committee's Democrats were expected to back her. NBC News said she would have needed 11 votes in the 21-member committee, so she could not afford to lose a single Republican if all Democrats opposed her. CBS News said the White House had already started talking to other possible candidates.

Why did Republicans hesitate?

CBS News said her nomination ran into trouble over her testimony on the abortion drug mifepristone and her role in carrying out President Trump's pro-vaping policies on the Domestic Policy Council. Sen. Josh Hawley, a Missouri Republican, was among the skeptics, according to CBS News, after Overton sidestepped questions about a long-promised safety study of mifepristone.

Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska had not said how they would vote. NBC News reported that Murkowski criticized Overton at her hearing for not taking a clear position on the drug.

Committee Chairman Bill Cassidy, a Louisiana Republican, questioned whether she had enough managerial experience. He said before her September hearing that he had strong concerns and later said he was undecided. CNN reported that the nomination also exposed tensions between the Make America Healthy Again movement and more traditional conservative circles, and quoted a person familiar with the situation as saying she is “not MAHA.”

What did the White House and Cassidy say about the vote?

CBS News reported that Cassidy told it late Tuesday he saw a possible path for Overton to advance out of his committee. The committee had not told the White House it lacked the votes, and two sources said vote-counting efforts were still underway when the White House shared its decision Tuesday evening.

Who runs the FDA now?

Kyle Diamantas is acting commissioner. The agency has had no Senate-confirmed leader since Dr. Marty Makary left in the spring, CBS News said. NBC News reported he resigned in May, in part over the administration's decision to authorize several fruit-flavored vaping products. CBS News cited sources who described friction over White House pressure on flavored vapes.

Why does it matter?

CBS News noted that the FDA oversees products that account for roughly 20% of consumer spending. NBC News said the agency is due to finish its safety review of mifepristone in March, one of the most consequential decisions it faces. The vacancy also extends a long stretch of upheaval at the top U.S. health agencies, NBC News reported.

What happens next?

Time is short. Democrats take control of the Senate in January, when Overton would have had to be renominated, and NBC News said her chances then would be slim. CBS News reported that the White House has spoken with candidates who could serve in an acting capacity and avoid Senate confirmation, and that two sources said Sen. Roger Marshall of Kansas, a doctor, is seeking the post. Marshall lost his reelection bid to Democrat Adam Hamilton earlier this month.

Cassidy said on CBS News' “Face the Nation” on Sunday that Republicans face a choice between a permanent commissioner who is not everyone's ideal pick and a series of short-term administrators with more influence from the health secretary.

Around Prague, based on reporting by CBS News, CNN, NBC News

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Nvidia Turmoil Rattles Wall Street: The Numbers Behind the Chip Stock Slump
Wall Street's three major indexes closed sharply lower Monday and slid again Tuesday as turmoil at Nvidia spread across the chip and artificial intelligence sectors. Investors are waiting for Nvidia's
Social Security COLA 2027: 3.6% Increase, SSI Amounts and Earnings Limits
Social Security benefits will rise 3.6 percent under the 2027 cost-of-living adjustment, the Social Security Administration says in a notice in the Federal Register. The increase is effective December
Chris LaNeve Nominated Army Chief: How Hegseth's Firing of Gen. George Led Here
President Donald Trump on Tuesday formally nominated Gen. Chris LaNeve to be Army chief of staff, the service's top uniformed officer. LaNeve has been filling the job on an acting basis since Defense
What We Know About the CFTC Order Pausing Kalshi’s Trump Speech Bets
Kalshi is pausing markets that let users bet on what President Trump will say, after a request from a federal regulator, a spokesperson for the prediction market confirmed to CBS News. The Commodity F
What the Apple Outage Means for iCloud, App Store and Apple Pay Users
Apple users reported trouble reaching a range of the company's services on Nov. 17, from iCloud and the App Store to Apple Music, Apple Pay and Apple Account sign-in, Digital Trends reported. Apple ha
Mullin Flew on Government Plane to LSU-Texas Game After FAA Ground Stop, Report Says
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin traveled on a government plane to Baton Rouge, Louisiana, on Saturday to watch Louisiana State University play the University of Texas at Austin, according

Related news

Wall Street's three major indexes closed sharply lower Monday and slid again Tuesday as turmoil at Nvidia spread across the chip and artificial intelligence sectors. Investors are waiting for Nvidia's first earnings report since CEO Jensen
Social Security benefits will rise 3.6 percent under the 2027 cost-of-living adjustment, the Social Security Administration says in a notice in the Federal Register. The increase is effective December 2026 and is payable in January 2027. Ho
President Donald Trump on Tuesday formally nominated Gen. Chris LaNeve to be Army chief of staff, the service's top uniformed officer. LaNeve has been filling the job on an acting basis since Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth abruptly removed
Kalshi is pausing markets that let users bet on what President Trump will say, after a request from a federal regulator, a spokesperson for the prediction market confirmed to CBS News. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission asked the comp
Apple users reported trouble reaching a range of the company's services on Nov. 17, from iCloud and the App Store to Apple Music, Apple Pay and Apple Account sign-in, Digital Trends reported. Apple has not publicly confirmed that all the pr
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin traveled on a government plane to Baton Rouge, Louisiana, on Saturday to watch Louisiana State University play the University of Texas at Austin, according to a New York Post report cited by Fox
Anthropic is on track to go public on Nasdaq this week, and expectations are that its shares will price above the $70 to $78 range the company has marketed. CNBC's David Faber reported that, citing multiple sources, while Bloomberg reported
Former President Joe Biden’s memoir, Promise Me, America, goes on sale Tuesday. According to ABC News, it covers his 2020 campaign, his four years in the White House and the 2024 race that ended when he stepped aside as the nominee. The boo
President Donald Trump warned Iran on Monday that it would face retaliation on an unprecedented scale if it attacked Washington, D.C. He was responding to a CNN report, relayed by Fox News, that Iran is weighing an attempt to kill senior ad
Grand Theft Auto 6 has racked up an estimated $1.45 billion in pre-order revenue before its release, according to the market research firm Sensor Tower, as reported by ABP Live. WN Hub, citing the same firm, put the figure at more than $1.4
A newly installed router is at the center of the investigation into the Federal Aviation Administration's nationwide ground stop last Friday, Axios reported. The failure exposed weaknesses in the FAA's aging telecommunications network and r
What happened in Modesto? Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents pepper-sprayed a pregnant U.S. citizen and threw her to the ground during a protest outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto, California, on Sunday, according to her