Petr Kolář, an adviser to the Czech president, does not believe the visit of American negotiators to Moscow brings the end of the war any closer. In his view, what is happening is more of a big theater meant to create the impression that Moscow is seeking peace, while its demands are unacceptable to both Ukraine and Europe. He said this in an interview with a Czech outlet.
Kyiv's position, Kolář says, is clear: first stop the fighting, then agree on security guarantees, and only then discuss a new security architecture for Europe. Russia sees the order the other way around and would like to start with the third point, that is, with “Yalta 2.” Kolář believes this cannot be accepted: it would mark the beginning of the end of the postwar order.
Moscow, he recalls, has repeatedly spoken of wanting to roll NATO back to its pre-1997 borders, so that some weapons and troops would not be stationed on the territory of the alliance's new members. In his view, this rests on Russia's image of itself as a “Third Rome” and a conviction that the West wants to seize it and destroy its traditional values. He stresses that NATO is a defensive alliance and that countries joined it because of their own attitude toward Russia.
Kolář said he does not trust Jared Kushner or Steve Witkoff at all, nor President Trump and his administration. He pointed to remarks by Vice President JD Vance that the United States has no obligation to Ukraine because it is not a member of the alliance. According to Kolář, Vance probably does not know what America committed to in 1994 under the Budapest Memorandum, when Russia, the United States, Britain and Ukraine agreed that Ukraine would give up nuclear weapons in exchange for security guarantees.
Russia, he believes, takes into account that the old Congress remains in office in the United States until the end of the year, and that Trump will be in power for two more years and will be able to get around congressional limits with executive orders.
Ukraine, he says, lacks the weapons it needs, although it has already freed itself from dependence on a number of American and European components and produces a lot on its own. Strikes on infrastructure and civilian targets are devastating, and the coming winter could be fatal for many Ukrainians. Moscow, Kolář says, wants to break them and force them to accept its terms, but it underestimates Ukrainians: the greater the pressure, the more stubborn they become. He added that NATO countries should strive to bring the Ukrainian army inside the alliance.
Kolář does not want to rule out entirely that Ukraine could give up Donbas, noting that negotiations have their own rules: the sides set maximum and minimum goals and maneuver between them. He cited the example of Finland, which lost part of Karelia but kept its independence and is now a member of the EU and NATO.
At the same time, Kolář stressed, it is not Russia that decides on membership in the EU and NATO, but the bloc itself and the candidate country. If Ukraine opts for a temporary territorial concession, it will be its own decision, which Europe will respect, but Kyiv must not be pressured. He explained the word “temporary” with the example of postwar Germany: it was divided for a long time but eventually reunified.
Around Prague, based on reporting by novinky.cz