A coronial inquest in New South Wales, Australia, has heard two sharply different accounts of the eight hours of life of a newborn known as Baby DH, who was born at home near Byron Bay and died after his parents repeatedly raised concerns with their doula. The doula, Amy Lou Smith, was not medically trained. She denies that her comments amounted to clinical advice.
The evidence was given on Wednesday at Lismore Local Court, according to reports by The Sydney Morning Herald and The Guardian. The inquest is examining four deaths of babies in the state’s northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024. Deputy State Coroner Joan Baptie earlier heard about two other deaths after a free birth outside the medical system. A coronial inquest is a fact-finding hearing into how people died.
The court heard that Baby DH was born in an inflatable pool at his parents’ home, with no medically trained person present. The Guardian reported that his father described him as floppy, with a purple body and hands and feet that were darker still. The Herald reported that the baby let out only a small cry.
According to the parents’ evidence, Smith reassured them several times. She said some babies take time to land, that some purple in the hands and feet was normal, and that the baby needed warming up. They said she described his labored breathing as “cute little noises.” The Guardian reported that the mother recalled the baby’s temperature as 34.5C, and that Smith suggested trying to raise it to 37C.
The parents said that five hours after the birth Smith left to set up a jumping castle for her son’s birthday. They said she later texted a photo of it while they were trying to reach a doctor. The father told the court the couple trusted Smith because of her long experience with births, and the Herald reported that they did not want to be seen as overreacting.
Smith, who was hired for $2,000 to help keep mother and baby safe, said her role was emotional support. She said the jumping castle was already set up and that she went home to rest and shower after nine-and-a-half hours with the family. She told the court the couple were happy for her to leave and that “Everything felt like it was OK.”
She denied saying the “cute little noises” remark and said she did not notice the baby’s body being purple. She told the court she twice recommended a hospital transfer if the parents were worried. The Herald reported there was no record of this in the parents’ police statement, given five days after the death. The mother said Smith never said she was unsure or offered to call anyone.
Smith also told the court she believed the parents would have called an ambulance if they had real concerns. She said she had been at 15 births over four years, nine of them alongside a midwife. She agreed that a clinically trained midwife working with a doula is now, in her view, the best model for a home birth.
The court heard that Baby DH had a complex heart abnormality that was not detected in pregnancy, because the mother had no ultrasounds. The Guardian reported that neonatologist Dr Paul Evans found the defect would have shown up on an X-ray, that the baby could have been treated, and that his death was not inevitable. The Herald reported that experts were split on whether earlier intervention would have prevented the death.
A GP eventually phoned the parents and told them to call Triple Zero, Australia’s emergency number. Paramedics spent 32 minutes trying to revive the baby. He was declared dead at Byron hospital, 10 minutes from the home.
The inquest is looking at what happens when families rely on support people who are not clinically trained for a birth outside the medical system. The court heard that Smith had no training in a newborn’s color, breathing or feeding, and that she learned CPR but was not familiar with applying it to newborns. She denied giving the parents the impression that she was. The Herald reported that a 2022 podcast video was played in court in which she criticized unnecessary medical intervention to start babies breathing.
The Herald also reported that Smith set up an online fundraiser for the family the day after the death, without their knowledge or consent. The mother said this added to their grief.
The inquest continues. Coroners make findings on how deaths occurred, and no findings in this case have been reported yet.
The Red Nose Grief and Loss Support Line is available 24 hours a day on 1300 308 307 for anyone affected by the loss of a pregnancy, stillbirth or the death of a baby or child.
Around Prague, based on reporting by The Sydney Morning Herald, The Guardian