A company that manages David Beckham's commercial interests is suing the beauty group that makes his fragrances, claiming the perfumes ended up in discount stores and a gas station bargain bin. According to The Independent and ABC News, DB Ventures wants at least $41 million in damages for breach of its licensing agreement.
The defendant, German beauty group Coty, denies the framing. It has asked a judge to dismiss the case and says the lawsuit is a way for DB Ventures to leave the deal early.
DB Ventures filed its claim in the New York Supreme Court against Coty, which makes and distributes a range of Beckham-branded fragrances and toiletries. The products include the Classic and Instinct lines and the eaux de toilette Intimately and Exquisite Leather.
The filing argues that Beckham's global brand stands for excellence and refinement, and that his products are meant to be a symbol of everyday luxury. Its lawyers say Beckham-branded products ended up in a bargain bin inside a gas station and at the British budget retailer Poundland. In their telling, that let the products be sold at dollar-store prices and tied the Beckham name to cheap, discount goods.
The legal document describes the discovery of the gas station sales with the words “desperation and greed,” according to the reports.
Coty has asked a judge to throw out the lawsuit, which was filed in April. The company argues that New York courts have no jurisdiction over the case. It also says DB Ventures is using the claim to “manufacture its early exit” from the licensing deal, so that the Beckham contracts can go to another firm, Interparfums.
Neither Coty nor DB Ventures responded immediately to requests for comment on Tuesday, according to the reports. None of the claims from either side has been tested in court.
Beckham played soccer for Manchester United and Real Madrid and captained the England men's national team. He has built a business career that includes co-ownership of the soccer team Inter Miami. He was knighted last year by King Charles III and is known as Sir David.
For DB Ventures, the case is about protecting how a premium brand is presented and about money: at least $41 million. For Coty, it is about whether the dispute belongs in a New York court at all and whether it can keep the licensing agreement from being ended on the terms DB Ventures wants.
For shoppers, the dispute shows how licensed celebrity products can end up in very different kinds of stores than the brand's owners intend. The reports do not say whether the sales continue or whether any products have been pulled. The next step is the judge's decision on Coty's request to dismiss the case.
Around Prague, based on reporting by The Independent, ABC News