Riad Bouchaker is due to be sentenced Monday at the Central Criminal Court in Dublin for a knife attack on a group of schoolchildren at Parnell Square in the Irish capital. The Irish Times reported that the attack left a five-year-old girl severely disabled.
Bouchaker, 52, was convicted by a jury in July of eight offenses, including the attempted murder of three children. The maximum sentence for attempted murder in Ireland is life imprisonment, according to the prosecution. Judge Tony Hunt, who heard victim impact statements and legal submissions at an earlier hearing, is due to give his ruling today.
The attack took place on Nov. 23, 2023. TheJournal.ie reported that the jury reached its verdicts after a three-week trial. Bouchaker was found guilty of attempting to murder three children: a five-year-old girl who was seriously injured, a six-year-old girl and a five-year-old boy.
He was also convicted of intentionally causing serious harm to Leanne Flynn, a childcare worker who tried to intervene, and of assault causing harm to two other children and to a teenager. The final offense was producing a knife in a way that was capable of causing serious injury. The Irish Times reported that the knife measured 36cm, including a 24cm blade.
The Irish Times reported that the most seriously injured child was stabbed in the heart. Her mother told the court in a victim impact statement that the girl has an acquired brain injury, uses a wheelchair, cannot walk or talk and is fed through a gastric tube. The mother said the child had no heartbeat and no oxygen reaching her brain for 40 minutes that day. She said the events changed her family's lives into “unrecognisable ones.” According to TheJournal.ie, the woman also said she and her husband worry about who will care for their daughter in the future.
The six-year-old girl was discharged from hospital a day after surgery to repair a scalp laceration and a displaced skull fragment, the paper reported. The five-year-old boy had a small neck wound treated with paper stitches.
Flynn was stabbed while trying to pull Bouchaker away from the children and needed life-saving surgery that included removal of her spleen. TheJournal.ie reported that she has been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder and has been unable to return to work. The Irish Times reported that a French teenage chef, Alan Lorena Guille, suffered minor scratches to his hand and face when he wrenched the knife away.
Prosecuting counsel Karl Finnegan said the prosecution's case was that Bouchaker intended to kill the children. He argued that the offense involving Flynn should be treated as falling in the higher range of the maximum sentence, which is life imprisonment, according to The Irish Times.
Bouchaker's senior counsel, who cannot be named because of a court order, urged the court to take into account what the lawyer described as his client's cognitive and intellectual limitations. The lawyer said Bouchaker could not grasp the concept of legal guilt, and that his legal team felt ethically bound to contest the case for him. TheJournal.ie reported that his lawyers argued a life sentence would not be appropriate. They pointed to earlier surgery to remove a benign brain tumor and a more recent diagnosis of moderate dementia.
The Irish Times reported that Hunt had earlier ruled Bouchaker fit to stand trial with accommodations, although psychiatrists disagreed on his fitness to plead. The paper said the disagreement related to an acquired brain injury, which it attributed to a pre-existing cognitive impairment combined with injuries he suffered when members of the public intervened at the scene. In interviews with gardaí, as Irish police are known, in December 2023, Bouchaker denied any intent to kill, the paper reported.
The ruling will set the length of time Bouchaker spends in prison for the attack, with the legal range running up to life imprisonment on the attempted murder counts. It will also bring to a close the main criminal case over an attack that, according to the court accounts, has had lifelong consequences for the most seriously injured child, who will require lifelong care, and has left a childcare worker with lasting physical and psychological harm.
The case has also raised questions about how courts weigh a defendant's cognitive impairment when deciding a sentence, an issue the defense put at the center of its submissions.
Hunt is expected to deliver his sentencing decision on Monday after adjourning the case from the earlier hearing.
Around Prague, based on reporting by The Irish Times, TheJournal.ie