Britain's Justice Secretary, Alex Norris, has asked the regulator of barristers in England and Wales to set new rules barring lawyers from using rape myths to defend their clients. Barristers who break such rules could face disciplinary action, including being barred from practice, according to The Guardian and the Evening Standard.
The intervention follows the trial of comedian Russell Brand at Southwark Crown Court in London. The Bar Standards Board (BSB), the body that regulates barristers, says it is already working on the issue, while the Bar Council, which represents barristers, has warned about the independence of the regulator and the rights of defendants.
Brand, 51, was convicted of attacks against four of the six women who gave evidence against him. He is serving a 10-and-a-half-year prison term for one count of rape and three sexual assaults, both outlets reported.
During the trial, the defense was accused of leaning on rape myths, which are false assumptions about how victims of sexual violence supposedly behave. The Guardian reported that these allegedly included the argument that accusers should not be believed because they had not screamed, kicked out or fled.
In his closing speech to the jury, Brand's barrister Ian Winter KC argued that the comedian could not be a rapist because his accusers had not “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave.” The Guardian also reported that Winter asked jurors whether they could be sure Brand had raped just three of the many women he had slept with over a decade. Winter has since reported himself to the BSB after criticism of his conduct inside the court and of an exchange with a Sunday Times journalist outside it, according to the Guardian.
In a letter to the BSB, reported by The Times and picked up by the Guardian and the Evening Standard, Norris said it is “unacceptable” for the profession to perpetuate myths about rape victims in court. He wrote that the board should send a firm message to barristers about the harm such myths cause, and that they are as out of place in a courtroom as they are in society at large.
Norris also warned that lawyers who flout the rules could face sanctions, up to being barred from practice.
A BSB spokesperson told The Times that the board agrees rape and sexual assault cases must be decided on evidence and not prejudice. The spokesperson said that is one reason the board set up an expert reference group to advise on tougher standards for barristers in rape and serious sexual offense cases, and added that the BSB will keep working urgently with the government on the issues raised.
A Bar Council spokesperson told the newspaper that a defendant who denies a rape offense has a right to have the evidence tested in court. The spokesperson also stressed that the BSB must remain independent of the government.
The two positions are not necessarily in direct conflict. The BSB has not publicly rejected Norris's call, and the Bar Council has not defended the use of rape myths. The disagreement centers on how far ministers should shape the rules that govern the legal profession and how to protect a defendant's ability to challenge the prosecution's case.
Any new rules would apply to barristers who act in rape and serious sexual offense cases in England and Wales. If the BSB tightens its standards, lawyers could face a clearer risk of discipline for arguments that rely on assumptions about how a victim should have reacted.
For complainants, the stated aim is that cases are judged on evidence rather than on stereotypes about behavior. For defendants, the Bar Council's position is that the right to test the evidence must remain intact. No new rules have been announced, and the BSB has not said what form any changes would take or when they would take effect.
The BSB says its expert reference group is continuing its work on standards for barristers in these cases, and that it will keep talking to the government. Winter's self-referral to the regulator is a separate matter, and no outcome has been reported.
Around Prague, based on reporting by Evening Standard, The Guardian, BBC News