Five European Union countries are expected to announce on Monday in Vienna that they will send rejected asylum seekers to a deportation hub in Rwanda, according to diplomatic sources cited by the BBC and two sources familiar with the proposal who spoke to The Independent. The plan would apply only to people who have used up every legal route to stay in the EU.
Germany, Denmark, Austria, Greece and the Netherlands said in September that they were working toward a deal with a non-EU country to host so-called return hubs. The BBC reported that the Rwanda site is expected to begin as a small pilot.
The BBC reported that legal challenges meant the British deal never took off, and that the incoming Labour government scrapped it in 2024.
The EU version differs in a key way. The British plan envisaged sending people to Rwanda to have their claims processed. The new scheme would cover only migrants whose claims have been finally rejected. It follows the approval of the EU's new Returns Regulation, which aims to speed up deportations and lets member states set up return hubs outside the bloc.
Rwanda said in August that it had begun “preliminary discussions” with several European states, the BBC reported.
For rejected asylum seekers in the five countries, the plan would mean they could be sent to a country they have no connection to rather than to their home country. Leaders of the five countries have repeatedly said the plans would comply with EU and international law, both outlets reported.
Human rights groups disagree. Céline Mias of the Danish Refugee Council asked what recourse people would have if their rights were violated and who would be held accountable. The Council of Europe said in July that return hubs posed “considerable human rights risks.” The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights said any host country should respect fundamental rights, that no one should be sent to a place where they face serious risk of persecution, and that unaccompanied children should not be sent to a return hub.
Human Rights Watch's Clementine de Montjoye said Rwanda's record of repression of dissent, arbitrary detention and support for armed rebels in neighboring Democratic Republic of Congo is a cause for concern. She argued that paying Kigali to host the program would give political leverage to a government responsible for serious abuses.
According to The Independent, European officials backing the hubs say the main purpose is deterrence rather than large-scale removals. They argue that migrants who pay smugglers thousands of euros for a dangerous journey, only to be sent to a third country, might decide not to make the trip.
Critics question that logic. Roberto Forin of the Mixed Migration Centre said enforcement changes how people travel, not whether they travel, and that smugglers adapt and raise their prices. The BBC added that with elections approaching in several EU nations, governments are under pressure to show they can control migration.
Details are expected Monday in Vienna. The International Organization for Migration, a United Nations agency, could play an ancillary role, the BBC reported. An IOM spokesperson said the agency is in discussions with some EU countries on plans for return hubs or similar mechanisms.
Around Prague, based on reporting by The Independent, BBC News, The Guardian