Five European countries announced Monday that they aim to open a “return hub” in Rwanda next year, a center where rejected asylum seekers could be sent. NBC News reported that the plan is meant to deter people from making the journey to Europe in the first place. No agreement has been signed yet, and human rights groups were quick to criticize the idea.
Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have led negotiations with countries outside the European Union. Here are the main questions the announcement raises.
Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker presented the plan alongside officials from the other four countries and Rwanda’s interior minister. The aim is to set up the first center in Rwanda next year. Denmark’s immigration minister, Morten Bødskov, said a fully negotiated agreement with Rwanda should be ready “within the next few months.”
The Independent reported that a joint statement called for quick negotiations so that the first deportation can take place in 2027. Officials were vague about how many migrants might be sent, according to NBC News.
The hub is intended for people who have been through the asylum process and exhausted their appeals. German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt said that sets the plan apart from the British scheme, which would have outsourced asylum proceedings to third countries. People whose claims are still being processed would not be covered, the Independent reported.
Rwanda’s interior minister, Vincent Biruta, said arrivals would be offered several options: voluntarily returning to their countries of origin, integrating into Rwandan society or relocating to another destination where they have a legal right to live.
The EU has worked for years to tighten migration rules and raise deportations of people who are not entitled to stay. Sending people to centers outside Europe has become a central part of that effort, NBC News reported. European lawmakers voted in June to let member states set up such centers on their own or in small groups.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen called the plan a “game changer” and said it would undercut human smugglers. She predicted that many other European countries would join. She also said the most important number is the one nobody will see, meaning the people who decide not to start the journey.
Human Rights Watch researcher Clementine de Montjoye described offshore deportation centers as an attempt by the EU to shift its responsibilities to other countries. She argued that paying Kigali would finance a government that the group says is responsible for serious abuses. Amnesty International Austria’s Aimée Stuflesser said the deal repeats mistakes of the past.
European officials insist the hubs would follow European and international law. Biruta said Rwanda would bring in organizations such as the U.N. refugee agency and set up an independent monitoring mechanism. The agency, UNHCR, said it supports return hubs only if they meet human rights standards and apply to people whose claims were denied after a full and fair assessment. It said it is holding “constructive discussions” with the five countries. The International Organization for Migration said it does not take part in state-to-state removal arrangements but is giving technical input.
Rwanda signed a deal with the U.K. in 2022 to take migrants who arrived as stowaways or in boats. The U.K. Supreme Court ruled the policy unlawful because Rwanda is not a safe third country for migrants sent there, and Keir Starmer scrapped it after taking office in 2024.
The Independent reported that Britain’s scheme cost £700 million, even though only four volunteers were sent to Kigali, according to then-Home Secretary Yvette Cooper. Rwanda later brought a case at the Permanent Court of Arbitration, and a panel rejected its multimillion-dollar claim against the U.K. in June.
The U.K. has not ruled out taking part. A spokesperson for Prime Minister Andy Burnham said the government will watch the scheme “with interest,” the Independent reported. For the five countries themselves, the practical details, including how many people would be sent and how rights would be protected, remain unsettled until an agreement is signed. UNHCR has said no agreement with it has been signed either.
Next steps are a negotiated deal with Rwanda in the coming months and, if it holds, the first center next year.
Around Prague, based on reporting by NBC News, The Independent