Australia's One Nation party has unveiled a plan to cut the country's yearly refugee intake by 90%, from 20,000 places to 2,000, and to scrap the visa program for the parents of migrants, according to The Guardian, ABC News and The Sydney Morning Herald. One Nation is a minor, populist-right party led by Senator Pauline Hanson. She announced the policy on Tuesday.
The party's critics, including Foreign Minister Penny Wong, say the plan would be harsh and divisive. Hanson says Australians must be looked after first.
Hanson says the cuts would save taxpayers heavily. Reports differ on the exact figure: The Guardian said she claimed more than $140 billion over 10 years, ABC News reported a $100 billion saving over the decade, and the Herald cited One Nation calculations of $140 billion over the lifetimes of those who would otherwise have arrived.
The party says its estimate relies on Treasury modelling. The Guardian reported that One Nation's analysis, adjusted for inflation, put the lifetime cost of a humanitarian entrant at $523,000, while Treasury modelling from December 2021 found a cost of $400,000, with 90% of it borne by the federal government. Hanson told reporters the average cost per person is about $500,000 over a lifetime.
The policy has not been costed by the Parliamentary Budget Office, the independent body that assesses party policies. Hanson told ABC News such modelling is not appropriate for a long-term policy, a position the broadcaster noted sits alongside the office's record of providing long-term analysis when asked.
Labor has committed to keeping the refugee intake at 20,000 a year. ABC News reported that in August Prime Minister Anthony Albanese personally stopped speculation the government would lower it to 13,750. The Coalition, led by Angus Taylor, has promised to halve the intake to 10,000.
Wong accused One Nation of trying to divide the country, saying Australia has the right balance and that the party's figures should be checked. She said displacement worldwide is at its highest since World War II and that Australia's contribution is small. She also called ending parent visas “very harsh,” according to ABC News.
The Guardian noted that migrants from countries on the government's “do not travel” list, including Iran, Lebanon, Syria and Somalia, would still be banned from entering.
If the plan were enacted, families in Australia would no longer be able to apply for permanent visas for their parents. They would instead have to sponsor them, according to Hanson, or bring them for visits of three, six or 12 months. Refugees seeking resettlement would compete for 2,000 places a year rather than 20,000.
The proposal remains a party policy: One Nation is a minor party, and both Labor and the Coalition have different intake plans. The Herald reported that all three parties accept that the post-pandemic migration surge has hurt housing affordability, so migration is expected to remain a central fight at the next election.
The policy follows the party's September plan to cut 750,000 temporary visa holders over three years under what it calls net-negative migration, after which annual net overseas migration would be capped at 130,000, ABC News reported.
Around Prague, based on reporting by The Sydney Morning Herald, The Guardian, ABC News Australia