A childminder in Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland, was sentenced to two years in prison on Friday after admitting she neglected and abandoned children in her care. Amanda Mathewson, 55, was looking after 27 children on the day she was arrested, according to Metro, even though she was licensed to care for only eight.
The case has raised questions about how a childminder who had been rated highly by the care regulator was able to carry on for nearly a year. The regulator, the Care Inspectorate, says it has since changed how it works.
Angus told The Times, as quoted by Metro, that the back door was open and five school-aged children were waiting in the garden with no adult. Inside, 22 more children were unattended. Twelve of the 27 had not yet started primary school, and one toddler was crying under the kitchen table, Metro reported.
His sons were upstairs in a very hot spare room with nine other children under five, two of them strapped into buggies. He said the blinds were drawn, the children had no food, water, toys or activities, and the only thing to watch was a television.
When Mathewson returned from the school run, Angus confronted her and she slumped, he said, as her story fell apart. Parents then began arriving as he called police.
Metro reported that parents had seen their children come home thirsty, in dirty nappies or with wet underwear, and in clean clothes after supposedly messy meals. The daily logs she gave parents were found by police to be misleading and false. When one boy complained that he was being put upstairs in a buggy, she told his parents he had simply fallen asleep.
The sheriff said Mathewson’s qualifications and experience meant she understood how vulnerable babies and young children are and how much supervision they need. He said the potential for harm was “enormous.” A non-custodial sentence, he said, would not reflect the seriousness of the offence.
For families, the case shows that a good inspection report does not guarantee what happens day to day. The Care Inspectorate said it has listened to parents who raised concerns and has reviewed its work. According to Metro, it has updated its inspection, complaints and conflict-of-interest procedures.
It said it has also created new ways to give feedback on childminders, during inspections and outside them, and has produced clearer resources so families know what to expect. A spokesperson said Mathewson broke the trust of families and children, and that the crime has been dealt with by the courts.
Around Prague, based on reporting by Metro