World By

What Went Wrong in the Dunfermline Childminder Case That Left 27 Children Unattended

A childminder in Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland, was sentenced to two years in prison on Friday after admitting she neglected and abandoned children in her care. Amanda Mathewson, 55, was looking after 27 children on the day she was arrested, according to Metro, even though she was licensed to care for only eight.

The case has raised questions about how a childminder who had been rated highly by the care regulator was able to carry on for nearly a year. The regulator, the Care Inspectorate, says it has since changed how it works.

How the case unfolded

What the father found

Angus told The Times, as quoted by Metro, that the back door was open and five school-aged children were waiting in the garden with no adult. Inside, 22 more children were unattended. Twelve of the 27 had not yet started primary school, and one toddler was crying under the kitchen table, Metro reported.

His sons were upstairs in a very hot spare room with nine other children under five, two of them strapped into buggies. He said the blinds were drawn, the children had no food, water, toys or activities, and the only thing to watch was a television.

When Mathewson returned from the school run, Angus confronted her and she slumped, he said, as her story fell apart. Parents then began arriving as he called police.

The warning signs parents noticed

Metro reported that parents had seen their children come home thirsty, in dirty nappies or with wet underwear, and in clean clothes after supposedly messy meals. The daily logs she gave parents were found by police to be misleading and false. When one boy complained that he was being put upstairs in a buggy, she told his parents he had simply fallen asleep.

What the court said

The sheriff said Mathewson’s qualifications and experience meant she understood how vulnerable babies and young children are and how much supervision they need. He said the potential for harm was “enormous.” A non-custodial sentence, he said, would not reflect the seriousness of the offence.

Why it matters for parents who use childminders

For families, the case shows that a good inspection report does not guarantee what happens day to day. The Care Inspectorate said it has listened to parents who raised concerns and has reviewed its work. According to Metro, it has updated its inspection, complaints and conflict-of-interest procedures.

It said it has also created new ways to give feedback on childminders, during inspections and outside them, and has produced clearer resources so families know what to expect. A spokesperson said Mathewson broke the trust of families and children, and that the crime has been dealt with by the courts.

Around Prague, based on reporting by Metro

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Billy Evans Speaks Out on “You Can See Everything” and Elizabeth Holmes
Billy Evans, the longtime partner of Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes, says he loves the documentary "You Can See Everything" even though it presents him as controlling and manipulative. In his first
RNC Chair Joe Gruters Faces a Challenge From Within as Trump Backs Him
A small but growing group of Republican National Committee members is pushing to replace Chairman Joe Gruters, whom President Donald Trump personally chose and wants to keep, ABC News reported. The le
What Xbox Project Helix Means for Players With PC and Console Libraries
Microsoft says its next-generation Xbox, known as Project Helix, is a console first and a PC second. It is designed to play games from a player's PC, according to details in the company's Xbox 25th An
New Orleans Cruise Ship Crash: What We Know About the Tanker's Steering Failure
Federal investigators say a tanker's steering system failed and left its rudder stuck to the right before it struck a docked cruise ship on the Mississippi River in New Orleans. The National Transport
College Football Rankings After Week 11: Texas Rises, LSU Slips, Flights Disrupted
Georgia remains the top-ranked team in college football after Week 11, while Texas strengthened its College Football Playoff case with a 22-21 win over LSU. According to The Tennessean, the weekend pr
Bowen Yang Returns to ‘SNL’ as Jensen Huang in John Mulaney’s Cold Open
Former "Saturday Night Live" cast member Bowen Yang returned to the show this weekend to play ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang in the opening sketch, NBC News reported. The sketch came just days after Huang

Related news

Prince Harry made an unannounced weekend visit to Lviv, in western Ukraine, to meet wounded veterans and watch Ukrainians compete in trials for next year’s Invictus Games. According to the BBC, he spent two days at events for veterans, and
Iran says it launched six drones at a U.S. military installation in Bahrain on Sunday, while Bahrain says its air defenses stopped the attacks before they reached their targets. The episode came a day after former Secretary of State Antony
A Jordanian court has sentenced three men to death by hanging over the shooting at a Greek Orthodox church that killed nine people last month, the country's military said Sunday. According to Al Jazeera and the BBC, the men are two brothers
Drones hit three cargo ships near the mouth of the Danube, Romanian authorities have said. Prime Minister Luca Niculescu condemned the incidents as a direct consequence of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. “These incidents are unacceptable and
Four countries have publicly pressed Israel to let tents and other relief supplies into Gaza as winter sets in. The foreign ministers of Australia, Canada, Italy and the United Kingdom said in a joint statement that 150,000 tents and other
The US aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt has entered the Arabian Sea. The news comes as US President Donald Trump, according to the German outlet Bild, is under growing pressure over possible new strikes on Iran.Trump has said the war
Congo's Ebola outbreak is still not under control six months after it was declared on May 15, according to Africa's top public health agency and government data cited by ABC News and Al Jazeera. More than 11,000 cases have been recorded, an
Noel Fielding, the Great British Bake-Off host and former on-screen partner of Russell Brand, said he was horrified by Brand's rape conviction and regrets jokes the two made together in the past. Fielding issued the statement to The Sun on
Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps said that two oil tankers taking an unauthorized route in the southern part of the Strait of Hormuz hit mines. According to the Guards, one of them, a supertanker carrying more than two million barre
Large crowds gathered in Prague's Letná Park on Sunday to oppose a government plan that would end the household fee for public television and radio and pay for the broadcasters from the state budget. Organizers put attendance in the hundred
Estonia will close all of its border crossings with Russia starting Dec. 1, Foreign Minister Margus Tsahkna said on X on Sunday. The move follows a suspected sabotage attempt at an Estonian defence company, which Estonian officials blame on
Hamas has confirmed that Samir Abu Younis, commander of its Rafah Brigade, was killed in an Israeli strike on the al-Mawasi area of Khan Younis in southern Gaza on Saturday. Al Jazeera, the BBC and ABC News in Australia all reported the dea