U.S. By

Judge Orders ICE to Free Canadian Dentist After Hearing Notice Went to Old Address

A federal judge in Minnesota has ordered immigration authorities to immediately release William Virgil Lizardo, a 32-year-old Canadian dentist and father, who was arrested by ICE after a hearing notice was mailed to an address that government records showed was out of date. Newsweek reported that U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis ruled on Sunday, Nov. 1, that the arrest and detention violated the Fourth and Fifth Amendments.

The ruling does not give Lizardo permanent residency or settle his immigration case. It does bar the government from detaining, transferring or removing him again unless it first gets the court's permission.

How the case reached a federal judge

According to court filings cited by Newsweek, Lizardo came to the United States in 2019 on an F-1 student visa to study at the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry. The steps that followed:

What the judge found

Davis described the facts of the case as “appalling,” according to Newsweek. He found an obvious risk that Lizardo had been wrongly deprived of his liberty. He also criticized the government for acknowledging a significant USCIS mistake while offering no relief.

Federal officials had argued the case should be dismissed because Lizardo's proceedings had been reopened and he was now held under a different provision of immigration law. Davis rejected that argument. He found no new warrant or custody determination supporting the detention, and he said the government had not shown evidence that Lizardo was a flight risk.

The judge noted that Lizardo had attended immigration appointments when he received notice, kept USCIS informed of address changes and maintained family and community ties. “It strains credulity to think that such a petitioner would flee,” Davis wrote.

Lizardo was released on his own recognizance, and officials were ordered to return his personal belongings. Newsweek reported that it contacted DHS and Lizardo's legal team for comment.

Why it matters: notice, detention and the courts

The case turns on a basic question in immigration enforcement: what happens when official notices go to the wrong place. Lizardo was ordered removed without knowing a hearing had been scheduled, and he was detained when he showed up voluntarily with a lawyer for a scheduled interview. The ruling shows that a person in that position can ask a federal court to review the detention while the immigration case continues.

The decision also adds to a broader pattern. Newsweek noted that federal judges and the Trump administration have repeatedly clashed over the limits of ICE's authority, especially on due process. It said the administration and DHS officials have often criticized rulings that restrict enforcement, accusing some judges of overstepping and obstructing its agenda.

What happens next

Lizardo's immigration proceedings remain reopened after the removal order was rescinded, and his appeal of the permanent residency denial was still pending at the time of the ruling. If the government wants to detain him again, the court said it must identify its legal authority and any materially changed circumstances. It would also have to show by clear and convincing evidence that release conditions could not reasonably ensure his appearance and community safety.

Around Prague, based on reporting by Newsweek

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Delta Atlanta Delays by the Numbers: Automation Glitch Hits Start of Thanksgiving Rush
A failure in Delta Air Lines' weight and balance automation system led to hundreds of flight delays at Atlanta's Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport on Sunday morning, according to Fox 5 Atlanta
What Trump's Contractor Order Means for Companies Facing Congress
Companies that do business with the federal government now have to tell the White House when Congress asks them for information about their work, under an executive order President Donald Trump signed
Amazon Black Friday 2026: When It Ends, Who Can Shop and Whether Prices Are Lower
Amazon's holiday sales are live. The company's Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday events started Nov. 19 and continue through Nov. 30, according to Mashable. Amazon said the events will bring millions
Why Is Bitcoin Up Today? BTC Rebounds 5.75% to $61,161 After Hitting Its Lowest Level Since September 2024
Bitcoin is up today, Sunday, Nov. 22, 2026, trading at $61,161 after a 5.75% gain over 24 hours. The price has bounced from a 24-hour low of $57,760 and a high of $61,239, a day after it touched about
What We Know About the Capture of Mexican Cartel Boss El Chapo Isidro
Mexican forces captured cartel boss Fausto Isidro Meza Flores, known as “El Chapo Isidro,” in a night of heavy gunfire in the city of Guasave in Sinaloa state, according to The Associated Press and NP
San Francisco Faces Record Tides as Mayor Urges Residents to Rethink Travel
San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie says the city faces an “extremely serious” situation this weekend. He cited forecasts from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the National Weather

Related news

A failure in Delta Air Lines' weight and balance automation system led to hundreds of flight delays at Atlanta's Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport on Sunday morning, according to Fox 5 Atlanta and Atlanta News First. The trouble bega
Companies that do business with the federal government now have to tell the White House when Congress asks them for information about their work, under an executive order President Donald Trump signed Friday, according to ABC News and NPR.
Amazon's holiday sales are live. The company's Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday events started Nov. 19 and continue through Nov. 30, according to Mashable. Amazon said the events will bring millions of deals across popular categories, wit
Bitcoin is up today, Sunday, Nov. 22, 2026, trading at $61,161 after a 5.75% gain over 24 hours. The price has bounced from a 24-hour low of $57,760 and a high of $61,239, a day after it touched about $55,300, its lowest since September 202
Mexican forces captured cartel boss Fausto Isidro Meza Flores, known as “El Chapo Isidro,” in a night of heavy gunfire in the city of Guasave in Sinaloa state, according to The Associated Press and NPR. The operation left at least 11 people
San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie says the city faces an “extremely serious” situation this weekend. He cited forecasts from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the National Weather Service, and he urged residents to cons
More than 51,000 units of toothpaste and mouthwash sold for children and adults have been recalled across the U.S. after federal testing found hormones in product samples, according to the Food and Drug Administration. The New York Post, ci
Immigration officers arrested two passengers on a jet bridge at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport on Saturday as travelers boarded an Alaska Airlines flight to Los Angeles, CBS News reported. The arrests delayed Flight 1306, which had be
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained Eva Yi Xie, a Princeton University Ph.D. student, at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport on Thursday night as she was preparing to fly home after presenting her research at a neuroscie
Forecasters at The Weather Channel and Fox Weather say storms on both coasts could disrupt Thanksgiving travel for millions of people, with delays possible before, during and after the holiday on Nov. 26. Here is what they say to expect. Wh
The FBI is investigating an apparent hack of the National Crime Information Center, a national law enforcement database the bureau maintains, according to reports published Saturday. The scope of the problem was not immediately clear, The A
President Donald Trump said Saturday he would work with Democrats to cap credit card interest rates and fees, reviving a 2024 campaign promise that went nowhere under a Republican Congress, CBS News reported. He made the remarks in an inter