On 29 October, the Supreme Administrative Court of Czechia sided with the Interior Ministry in its dispute with a Lebanese man, Ali Al M., whose residence permit the ministry had refused to extend. The case was sent back to the Liberec branch of the regional court in Ústí nad Labem, and for now the man does not have to leave the country.
According to the security services, the man, who has lived in Czechia for eight years, was interested in firearms and may have been linked to radical Islamist movements. The authorities also looked into his violence against his partner. In Czechia he has a family, a young son and a job.
As Seznam Zprávy previously found, over two years the man insulted or beat his partner at least fifteen times, often under the influence of cocaine. Police removed him from their shared apartment.
When it decided in May not to extend his stay, the ministry relied in part on photographs of the man in uniform holding an assault rifle, as well as on classified intelligence data.
On 19 August, the Liberec branch of the regional court concluded that the ministry’s evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate a threat to state security. The ministry filed a cassation appeal, and the Supreme Administrative Court disagreed with that verdict.
According to the court, the regional court erred by failing to assess individual pieces of information in relation to one another. It did not give enough weight to how the violence and contact with the drug scene fit together with an interest in weapons and possible sympathy for violent Islamist movements. It is precisely the combination of these circumstances, the court believes, that may point to a risk of violence extending beyond private life. At the same time, it did not say that the man is actually dangerous.
The regional court has been instructed to request details from the intelligence service that will make it possible to verify the source, reliability and timeliness of the classified data. Only then can it decide anew whether the ministry acted lawfully. Both cases returned to Liberec in early November, and proceedings are reportedly already under way.
The man is defending himself by citing his family life. He says his relationship with his partner has improved, that he is working and has started treatment for drug addiction. His partner, who previously complained of violence, has now said she wants him to stay in Czechia and take part in raising their son.
On 27 October, two days before the Supreme Administrative Court’s decision, the man supplemented his submission with new statements from his partner. In the court’s view, this does not change the error made by the regional court.
Around Prague guide on the topic: Insurance for residence permit renewal in Czechia: complete 2026 guide
Around Prague, based on reporting by novinky.cz