Neighbors of a new residential building in Prague's Kavčí hory district have lost their court fight over a construction project run by a company from the circle of lobbyist Roman Janoušek. At the end of October, the Municipal Court in Prague rejected their lawsuit, ruling that they filed their objection to the permit after the deadline had passed. The plaintiffs intend to take the case to higher courts.
In Kavčí hory, not far from the Czech Television building, a long-abandoned villa was recently demolished. A building with four above-ground floors and underground garages is to rise in its place. According to the plans, it will be a residential building, and the project is called Viladům Kavky.
The investor and owner of the plot, Sagnell Business, a company with Cypriot roots, obtained a building permit, but the neighbors found out about it only after it had already come into force. The city hall rejected their appeal as late, after which they sued the city.
The core of the complaint is how the decision was delivered. The Prague 4 building office had also brought in co-owners of land and houses on the opposite side of the street as parties to the proceedings. The number of parties rose to more than thirty, which allowed the office to skip sending the decision to each of them and simply post it on the official notice board. The closest neighbors did not notice it. According to their lawyer, Roman Sulanský, nobody checks the board regularly: people were presented with a fait accompli.
The law does indeed allow a decision to be announced by public notice if there are more than thirty parties. But the neighbors argue that it is questionable whether the office was entitled to include the owners of houses across the road. The lawsuit says those houses are separated from the construction site by a roadway and tall vegetation, and that the office held no on-site inspection that could have assessed whether the construction would affect them. Sulanský also says the decision could have been delivered in person to at least the residents of the nearest houses, and points to another case at the same office in which documents were sent individually to almost a hundred parties.
The Municipal Court in Prague dismissed the lawsuit: it considered it decisive that the appeal was filed after the legal deadline, and it rejected the argument that personal delivery was necessary. According to the lawyer, the plaintiffs now want to file a cassation complaint with the Supreme Administrative Court; an appeal to the Constitutional Court is not ruled out either.
Real estate law expert Vojtěch Křikava believes the chances will depend on whether the owners of the more distant houses could realistically have been affected by the construction, for example by traffic, noise or dust. He did not rule out that the office defined the circle of parties deliberately, but from what is known, he said, it cannot be concluded that the office broke the law, and the mistake alone does not prove bad intent.
Journalists who examined the case write that a number of threads lead from Sagnell Business to Roman Janoušek, who lives about a two-minute walk from the future construction site. In the spring it emerged that the company owns the yacht Zilvar, on which the lobbyist sails the Adriatic, and several properties in Prague and Špindlerův Mlýn. Janoušek did not answer questions. The company's lawyer, Vít Kučera, cited attorney-client privilege.
The office's motives are unknown. Aleš Berný, a spokesman for the Prague 4 office, explained nothing: according to him, the construction is finally permitted, but the proceedings are non-public and the relevant file is not currently in the building department.
The plot has a colorful ownership history. The villa was owned for three and a half years by Jiří Toman, who under mayor Pavel Bém was an influential head of the city's investment department. A source close to Janoušek claims that Toman handles construction matters for the lobbyist, but this cannot be verified: Toman did not respond.
The permit was issued when the transfer contract with Sagnell Business had already been signed. According to the land registry, the villa changed hands four times in a short period, and its price rose from 20 to almost 45 million crowns.
According to the sign on the fence, the house will be built by SPS Engineering. Half of it is owned by Petr Sadlo, who races bicycles with Janoušek for the Zilvar team. The same firm recently renovated a building on Malé náměstí, where Sagnell Business is based; its owner, the company Fezre, is linked to it and controlled through a Cypriot structure.
Around Prague guide on the topic: Квартиры в Праге за 10 лет: цены выросли в 2,5 раза — но только на бумаге
Around Prague, based on reporting by seznamzpravy.cz