The leaders of the United States, China and Russia held an unprecedented three-way summit in the Chinese tech hub of Shenzhen on Thursday, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) gathering. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin pledged closer cooperation on energy supplies and nuclear risks, but it remains unclear what the meeting will actually change.
Xi chaired the session after a series of bilateral meetings among the leaders. NBC News put the meeting at 90 minutes, while Al Jazeera described it as more than an hour. Trump said before talks began that the three leaders were making history, noting that their countries hold the world's three biggest nuclear arsenals. NBC reported that comparisons have already been drawn with the 1945 Yalta Conference.
Al Jazeera reported that the three released a joint declaration they described as a peace declaration. According to Chinese state media, it reaffirms the importance of stable energy flows and commits the countries to a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation. The leaders also pledged to maintain strategic stability and international security.
NBC News reported a wrinkle: identical statements were released by China and Russia, but not yet by the U.S. Those statements also called on the three countries to increase their energy production and supply, which NBC noted would fuel Russia's oil-driven war economy.
Trump pressed for new curbs on nuclear arms. The last remaining nuclear treaty between Washington and Moscow lapsed this year, and NBC reported that China, whose arsenal is smaller than the other two, has resisted calls to join a new one. Xi said nuclear weapons should be comprehensively banned and destroyed, and that a nuclear war cannot be won and must not be fought. Putin said it was up to the three countries to strengthen the system of international law, and he also raised food and energy security.
Only in limited ways, according to Al Jazeera. The report said the declaration made no reference to the war on Iran, other than Trump repeating that Tehran cannot have a nuclear weapon. Trump also said Xi agreed that the Strait of Hormuz, through which a fifth of the world's oil supplies previously passed, must stay open. Iran has said its nuclear program is for civilian purposes.
A Kremlin spokesperson said Ukraine was not the central topic of the trilateral session, although it was central to Putin's earlier bilateral talks with Trump. Trump asked Xi to help resolve the war. In an interview with NBC News, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said the U.S. and China could end the war by imposing sanctions on, or threatening to cut trade with, Russia.
The declaration included a pointed critique of the International Criminal Court. The leaders demanded that the court and similar institutions not abuse their positions. None of the three countries is a member of the court. Al Jazeera noted that the court has a warrant out for Putin over the war in Ukraine, which is one reason he has skipped recent G20 summits.
Al Jazeera pointed out that wars involving the U.S. and Iran and Russia and Ukraine have taken a heavy toll on economies and people worldwide, and that global energy supplies have been strained since the Strait of Hormuz was closed. Stable energy flows are therefore the most direct everyday stake. However, the outlet said there is no end in sight to either war, and it is unclear how the promise on energy will be fulfilled given the countries' differing priorities.
Next month, Trump is hosting the G20 summit in Miami, Florida, and Xi is almost certain to attend. Trump has invited Putin as well. The U.S. is not a member of the ICC and so has no obligation to arrest him. Al Jazeera framed the open question as whether the Shenzhen meeting is the start of a so-called G3, adding that the coming weeks should show. Putin said the discussion was very frank and helped the leaders better understand one another.
Around Prague, based on reporting by Fox News, NBC News, Al Jazeera