The UN climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, are heading toward a tense close after the COP31 presidency released a new draft agreement that does not mention fossil fuels. The omission deepened a stand-off between the European Union and oil-producing countries, TheJournal.ie and The Irish Times reported, citing AFP and AP.
The proposal needs consensus approval from nearly 200 nations at a closing session Sunday. They have struggled to close their differences over two weeks of negotiations, and an EU official told AFP there was a very real possibility that the summit ends with no deal.
The text came from Murat Kurum, Turkey's environment minister and co-president of the conference, according to The Irish Times. It was released at 3 a.m. local time Sunday. Negotiators had only about three hours to object or request changes before it went to what may be the final meeting, where countries will accept it, reject it or state reservations. The conference was due to end Friday and is now in double overtime.
The 10-page document refers to the 2023 Dubai agreement to transition away from fossil fuels, but the words fossil, oil, coal and phase-out do not appear in it, The Irish Times reported. An earlier draft this week called for a faster phase-out, while a pared-down version released Thursday removed every mention of coal, oil and gas, according to TheJournal.ie.
The draft keeps Turkey's electrification goal: raising electricity's share of total final energy use from about 21% today to 35% by 2035. It also backs carbon capture and storage, with a target of capturing, reusing and storing one billion metric tons of carbon.
Turkey and Australia, the summit's co-hosts, point to electrification as a way to cut emissions and strengthen energy security. It means replacing technologies that burn fossil fuels directly, such as diesel cars and gas heating, with electric alternatives, TheJournal.ie explained. The hosts also argue that carbon capture could help industrial polluters that cannot easily switch to renewables.
Oil-producing countries have been pushing hard against stronger language. A German official told AFP that those countries were putting up a fierce fight and that the outcome was uncertain. A Saudi official declined to comment to AFP. Saudi Arabia, India and Kenya have also tried to delay the next reports from the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which the draft says are important for a 2028 stock take of global carbon-cutting efforts.
An EU official told AFP the proposal was a step backward and said they were more pessimistic than a day earlier. Michael Joseph, Antigua and Barbuda's environment minister, said he was very disappointed and could not honestly say he was fine with the text passing in its current state.
Panama has vowed to formally object to any final agreement that does not cap oil production, acknowledge missed warming goals and strengthen adaptation finance. Its environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, said the talks were being held hostage by a petroleum mafia.
Scientists and analysts criticized the text too. Alden Meyer of the think tank E3G noted that fossil fuels went unmentioned in final COP decisions for more than 25 years, until the Dubai deal, and said leaving the signal out now would be a real setback. Bill Hare of Climate Analytics said electrification powered by coal and gas does not limit warming. Some nations and activists want the target to say explicitly that the electricity must be clean.
Carbon capture drew criticism as well. TheJournal.ie described it as a technology championed by the fossil fuel industry but criticized as costly and ineffective at cutting emissions, and The Irish Times said experts have warned it could become an excuse to keep investing in fossil fuels.
For households, the backdrop is already difficult. TheJournal.ie said the summit is taking place amid soaring energy prices and geopolitical tension linked to the war in Iran. Around one-third of global electricity is generated from coal and another fifth from fossil gas, so how the world's power is produced matters to the electrification goal.
The talks also face pressure to show progress in a year of climate-linked disasters, including deadly heatwaves in Europe and devastating flooding in Nepal. Climate-vulnerable countries want more detail on promises of financial help to adapt to a warmer world. A $120 billion adaptation target was removed from the text, which angered developing nations. Harjeet Singh of the Satat Sampada Climate Foundation said rich countries were offering a conversation instead of cash.
The draft also expresses deep concern that global warming will cross 1.5C above pre-industrial levels within the next few years, a point countries have disputed.
Countries will decide at the closing session whether to accept the draft. Organizers worry that so many delegates are leaving Antalya that there may not be enough people left in the room to approve it, The Irish Times reported.
Around Prague, based on reporting by TheJournal.ie, The Irish Times