Crime By

Public execution in the US: Pentagon to stream Hasan firing squad

Execution live online: US prepares public execution of army psychiatrist

The Pentagon intends to broadcast live online the execution of former army psychiatrist Nidal Hasan, who in 2009 shot dead 13 service members at a base in Texas and wounded about thirty others. The decision raises a question: does a public execution really deter criminals, or is the death penalty turning into ordinary spectacle?

A firing squad is due to carry out the sentence on December 3 at the very base where Hasan committed the killings. It will be the first US military execution in more than 65 years. The Pentagon said it will show it online, but has not yet named the platform.

Execution as spectacle

“I consider this utterly reprehensible and a step in the wrong direction,” said priest, theologian and ethicist Marek Orko Vácha. He recalled times when people went to watch executions as a matter of course. “It is high time we closed this page of the Middle Ages. Even if the death penalty is justified, the state must separately explain why it is justified to turn a human death into a public spectacle,” he said.

US politics expert Jakub Lepš, who teaches at the University of New York in Prague and works in politics for the TOP 09 party, notes that the US abandoned public executions decades ago: the last one took place roughly 90 years ago. According to him, a live internet broadcast of an execution would be an absolute novelty in American history.

Does death on screen deter?

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth defends the public broadcast by saying it should show people the grave consequences of such crimes. However, according to Vácha, it is not even clear whether the death penalty itself deters crime, and the effect of a public execution is even more contested and hard to measure.

Moreover, watching an execution may change society’s attitude to violence. “A public execution can teach viewers to see the death penalty as an acceptable and, in a sense, glorified response to evil, and in some cases it can even turn criminals into martyrs and advertise them and their supporters,” Vácha believes.

Americans themselves doubt the deterrent effect. According to a July Pew Research Center survey, 66% of respondents support the death penalty for convicted murderers, but 59% believe it does not deter serious crime. “The same Americans support the death penalty, but doubt its deterrent effect and are not quite sure that its application will be free of judicial error,” Lepš summed up.

Although Hasan’s guilt is not in doubt, Vácha points to another problem: once recordings of the execution reach the internet, it will be impossible to control how they are used. They could be edited, mocked or used for all sorts of purposes, and the state will lose control over them. Vácha himself opposes the death penalty, but stresses that even if society considers it just, it does not follow that people should watch it being carried out. “The justification of a punishment does not imply the justification of broadcasting it.”

From pardons to executions

Hasan can still challenge the execution by filing a petition in a civil court to review the lawfulness of his detention. According to military law specialists, this could noticeably delay the carrying out of the sentence.

Former US President Joe Biden, at the end of his term, spared 37 of the 40 inmates awaiting execution in American prisons, but his successor Donald Trump takes a different approach. According to Lepš, this reflects the current administration’s conservative course and the traditional Christian understanding of justice with its principle of “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth”. The conviction of Secretary Hegseth, who advocates the broadcast, may also play a role: “His position does not surprise me. It is also tied to his religious views,” says Lepš.

The debate on the death penalty was recently fuelled by the case of Christa Pike. The convicted murderer survived an attempted execution by lethal injection in Tennessee on September 30: the two doses administered did not kill her, and she ended up in hospital. The state’s governor then suspended all executions until the end of the year. Could this case have influenced the decision to show Hasan’s execution by firing squad? Lepš does not rule out the possibility: “Perhaps they see this as a chance to rehabilitate the death penalty in the eyes of the public.” A direct link between the Pike case and Hasan’s planned execution has not, however, been confirmed.

Around Prague, based on reporting by seznamzpravy.cz

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

What Iowa's Planned Lead Azide Blast Means for Residents Near an Army Plant
The U.S. Army plans to detonate about 5 tons of lead azide, a chemical used to set off munitions, at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant on Friday. Officials are asking residents of the nearby town of Midd
Begich Wins Alaska's Lone House Seat as Democrats Take Senate and Governor
Rep. Nick Begich, a Republican, won re-election to Alaska's only U.S. House seat after the state's ranked-choice tabulation, Fox News reported. The race was called at 9:27 p.m. ET on Wednesday, more t
Marlon Humphrey Apologizes to Baltimore After Podcast Remark About Criminals
Baltimore Ravens cornerback Marlon Humphrey apologized Wednesday after a joke on his podcast drew backlash from fans and the city's mayor. According to The Guardian, Mayor Brandon Scott said the apolo
GTA 6 Launch Has Fans Taking Time Off Work, but Economists See Limited Impact
Fans of Grand Theft Auto 6 are clearing their calendars for the game’s release, CBS News reported. Data from payroll processor Gusto shows paid time off requests for launch day are up 9% compared with
Judge Extends Block on Trump's 250-Foot Triumphal Arch Near Arlington Until Dec. 3
A federal judge has extended an order blocking construction of President Donald Trump’s proposed triumphal arch near Arlington, across the river from Washington, D.C., until at least Dec. 3, Fox News
Cornyn Blocks Trump’s Texas Judge Pick Elliot Gaiser: What Happened and Why
Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas has blocked President Donald Trump’s nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser, a senior Justice Department official, to a federal district court seat in the Dallas area, CBS

Related news

A court in Czechia has sentenced a disabled pensioner to 13 years in prison for killing his partner. The man stabbed the woman twice in the chest with a kitchen knife after an argument that began over the bedroom light. The verdict was hand
The Czech Constitutional Court has dismissed a complaint from a man whose 200,000 crowns were seized by police, money that investigators say was meant to buy methamphetamine. According to the court, the officers did not violate the complain
The plenum of the Czech Constitutional Court, meaning the assembly of all its judges, has ruled that if an offender intentionally causes non-material harm to a victim, a court may not reduce the compensation on the grounds that paying it wo
Reporter Jakub Mikel spent two months under a false name in the Czech cell of the neo-Nazi organization Active Club, headquartered in Prague’s Libeň district. According to his investigation, the group recruits teenagers through Telegram, an
The Regional Court in Brno has confirmed a three-year suspended prison sentence with a five-year probation period for a 37-year-old man who shot a fleeing thief in the back. Prosecutors had classed the act as attempted murder, which carries
Police in the US have arrested a father who left his six-year-old daughter alone in a queue outside a Target shopping centre around 1 a.m. to get Pokémon cards. The man was charged with child neglect; the girl was not hurt. His trial is set
In Brno, police have detained a man who, under the influence of drugs, got into a flat from the terrace where two children were home. The older girl tried to keep him out and was hurt by shards of glass, police spokesman Petr Vala said.A pa
An unknown driver hit a rare hunting dog on the road between Slušovice and Lípa at around 11:40 a.m. on Saturday, Nov. 14, and drove away from the scene. The dog, a Briquet Griffon Vendéen, ran onto the road during a hunt and died of its in
Traffic police in the Vyškov district have detained a driver who was banned from driving, rammed a patrol car and tried to get away. The man is suspected of violence against a public official and of obstructing an official decision, and fac
Near Tábor in South Bohemia, a drunk driver crashed his Volkswagen into a concrete pole. Three men aged 30 to 40 suffered serious injuries and were taken to hospitals in České Budějovice.According to South Bohemian police spokeswoman Lenka
On Thursday afternoon, a 60-year-old man got behind the wheel with 2.54 per mille of alcohol in his blood and never made it home: according to Zlín police, he collided with two parked cars and a stone fence post. The damage is preliminarily
Police in the Vyškov area of South Moravia have detained a driver who is banned from driving: he tried to escape a patrol first by car and then on foot. South Moravia police spokesman David Chaloupka said the man now faces criminal prosecut