Science & Space By

Starlink Outages in Ukraine Spark Call to Strip Musk of Control

Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman says control of Starlink should be taken away from Elon Musk, arguing that a private individual should not be able to shape a country's security. According to India Today, he made the case in a Substack post after reports of Starlink disruptions that hampered Ukraine's military.

The dispute puts a question in front of governments and the public: what happens when a front-line military depends on a network that a single company, and its owner, controls?

What set off the argument

Krugman's post responded to a Wall Street Journal report about Musk's alleged role in Starlink disruptions in Ukraine, India Today reported. Musk has since acknowledged restricting the service there. Ukraine says it uses Starlink for defensive purposes, and that recent disruptions hurt its defensive operations for more than a week.

The Atlantic reported that a confidential memo went to Ukrainian military officers on Oct. 11, telling them to prepare for a possible loss of Starlink access. Service problems began two days later, according to the magazine, grounding drones and halting operations in parts of the war zone. The Atlantic also cited two people familiar with a mission in which Ukrainian naval drones were lost in the Black Sea.

Krugman's case: a military asset needs public control

Krugman, according to India Today, calls Starlink a crucial military asset. He argues that decisions about who can use it are foreign policy and national security matters that belong to governments, not business owners.

To make the point, he compares Starlink with weapons from defense contractors. He asks readers to imagine Lockheed Martin, maker of the F-16 jets Taiwan uses, abruptly cutting off spare parts, upgrades and support, perhaps as part of a deal with China. In his view, the U.S. government would not treat that as an ordinary business choice and would be expected to step in.

He concludes that control of Starlink must be taken from Musk "one way or another." His post also uses harsh personal language about Musk, which this article does not repeat.

Musk's response: the service was misused

Musk defended the restrictions in an Oct. 25 post on X. He said using Starlink, a civilian commercial service, for offensive drone strikes that kill people has never been allowed. According to India Today, he also separated Starlink from Starshield, a SpaceX service built for military customers. He said the U.S. government controls Starshield and decides how it is used.

Musk also acknowledged how much Ukraine relies on the network. He wrote that "the Ukrainian front line would collapse immediately" if Starlink were switched off, calling that a statement of fact rather than a threat. He described Starlink as the only system that cannot be jammed or destroyed, at least for now.

Ukraine rejects the claim of offensive use, saying it has used the service defensively.

How Starlink became central to the war

After Russia invaded in 2022, missile strikes and cyberattacks damaged Ukraine's digital infrastructure. Musk donated thousands of Starlink antennas to hospitals, power plants, government offices and humanitarian groups, India Today reported. The Ukrainian military soon used the network to fly drones and keep communications running.

Russian forces do not have access to Starlink and cannot easily jam its signals, which gave Ukraine an edge. India Today also reported that Russia is building its own rival to Starshield. A senior U.S. military officer told The Atlantic, "Without Starlink, the war would grind to a halt."

What's at stake beyond one company

The dispute is less about consumers than about dependence. Krugman argues that Ukraine's biggest technological advantage could also be its biggest weakness, because a private company's decisions can directly affect its ability to fight. Musk's own warning about a front-line collapse points to the same reliance.

The two sides disagree about the remedy and the rules. Krugman wants control moved away from Musk and treated as a government matter. Musk says the issue is compliance with the terms of a civilian service and points to Starshield as the government-controlled option. The sources do not describe any official U.S. action in response to Krugman's call, and his argument remains an opinion, not a policy proposal under consideration.

Around Prague, based on reporting by India Today

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More science news

A Rival to Dark Matter Theory Passes Tests and Puts the Universe at 26.7 Billion Years
A rival to the standard picture of the universe has passed a series of tests, according to Universe Today. Researchers at the University of Ottawa say their model reproduces key observations without d
Two Mars Spacecraft Go Quiet at Once as NASA Chases Radio and Wheel Glitches
Two of NASA's Mars explorers have paused their science work because of technical problems, the agency announced Thursday, Nov. 19, according to Space.com. The Perseverance rover is dealing with a radi
Climate Talks Stall Over Fossil Fuels and Money as COP31 Runs Through the Night
Negotiations at the COP31 UN climate summit in Turkey are deadlocked after running through the night, the BBC reported. Countries have not been able to agree on a new global climate deal, and two figh
SpaceX Launches Secret Payload for Space Force as Falcon 9 Booster Flies an 11th Time
SpaceX launched a classified mission for the U.S. Space Force on Nov. 20, sending an undisclosed payload to orbit from California's central coast, Space.com reported. The rocket's first stage returned
X-Ray Telescope Bound for Mercury Wakes Up After 8 Years and Sees the Crab Nebula
An X-ray telescope that has traveled to Mercury for eight years has made its first observation of a distant object, and it is working better than scientists expected, according to ScienceDaily, citing
Black Saturn: A Black Hole Ringed by a Donut-Shaped One Gets a New Solution
A theoretical physicist has described a more general version of one of the strangest objects permitted by Einstein’s equations: the Black Saturn, a black hole shaped like a donut with a second black h

Related news

A rival to the standard picture of the universe has passed a series of tests, according to Universe Today. Researchers at the University of Ottawa say their model reproduces key observations without dark matter or dark energy, and it implie
Two of NASA's Mars explorers have paused their science work because of technical problems, the agency announced Thursday, Nov. 19, according to Space.com. The Perseverance rover is dealing with a radio fault, and the Mars Odyssey orbiter ha
Negotiations at the COP31 UN climate summit in Turkey are deadlocked after running through the night, the BBC reported. Countries have not been able to agree on a new global climate deal, and two fights are holding things up: whether the te
SpaceX launched a classified mission for the U.S. Space Force on Nov. 20, sending an undisclosed payload to orbit from California's central coast, Space.com reported. The rocket's first stage returned safely, but the public did not see the
An X-ray telescope that has traveled to Mercury for eight years has made its first observation of a distant object, and it is working better than scientists expected, according to ScienceDaily, citing the University of Leicester. The instru
A theoretical physicist has described a more general version of one of the strangest objects permitted by Einstein’s equations: the Black Saturn, a black hole shaped like a donut with a second black hole sitting in its center. The work, rep
Severe premenstrual syndrome may not be a single pattern of symptoms. Researchers at Uppsala University in Sweden have identified three distinct symptom timelines in premenstrual dysphoric disorder, or PMDD, according to ScienceAlert. The f
Scientists have found chemical marks on DNA in the brains of people with post-traumatic stress disorder that do not appear in people without the condition, and that also look different from the marks seen in depression, Live Science reporte
Researchers at MIT say they have found a way to keep machine-learning models of chaotic systems from drifting into predictions that could never happen in the real world. According to MIT News, the method builds physical limits directly into
NASA has selected 302 projects from small businesses for up to $171 million in early-stage funding, the agency announced. The awards target technology for exploring the Moon and Mars, including work tied to Artemis and a planned U.S. Moon B
Astronomers looking for planets have found a triple star system only 28 light-years from Earth that one of the researchers says should not exist. According to Universe Today, the team went searching for an exoplanet around a nearby red dwar
Biologists have described a new species of egg-eating snake from forests near the Bale Mountains in southeastern Ethiopia, according to Popular Science. The white-throated egg-eater, Dasypeltis albigularis, is a tiny, nonvenomous snake that