A theoretical physicist has described a more general version of one of the strangest objects permitted by Einstein’s equations: the Black Saturn, a black hole shaped like a donut with a second black hole sitting in its center. The work, reported by ScienceAlert, appears in a preprint on arXiv, which means it has been posted publicly but has not been confirmed by peer review.
The new mathematics lets both black holes spin in two independent planes at once. It shows that both can reach a state called extremality together, a result earlier versions could not describe.
An ordinary black hole is a spherical region of space from which light cannot escape. Einstein’s general theory of relativity also allows stranger shapes, though. The theory still applies the same way if you add one extra spatial dimension to the three we know, but that extra dimension permits geometries that cannot exist in our familiar four-dimensional spacetime (three of space and one of time).
In five-dimensional spacetime, the equations allow a black hole with a ring-shaped event horizon, a donut, or torus, with a real hole in the middle. Put a spherical black hole in that hole and you have a Black Saturn. Each of the two has its own event horizon, the boundary beyond which escape would require moving faster than light.
The ring stays in balance because it rotates. Without enough angular momentum, its own gravity would make it collapse. The central black hole is closer to the four-dimensional kind we already know.
The first mathematical description of a Black Saturn was published in 2007. It had a limit: the two black holes could rotate in only one plane. In five dimensions, objects can rotate in two independent planes simultaneously, but including both makes the math much harder.
Jay Armas of the University of Amsterdam took on that problem. His preprint presents a solution in which both black holes can rotate in both planes. “The space of black holes in higher-dimensional vacuum gravity is richer than its four-dimensional counterpart,” he writes.
Black holes can only hold so much angular momentum relative to their mass. At that limit, a black hole is extremal, and its Hawking temperature falls to absolute zero. An extremal black hole gives off none of the Hawking radiation that comes from quantum effects near the event horizon.
In five dimensions, a black hole has to spin in both independent planes to reach extremality without losing its event horizon altogether. Armas’s solution shows that both black holes in a Black Saturn can be extremal at the same time and still keep their own horizons. ScienceAlert described it as the first known exact solution to Einstein’s equations showing two separate black holes in this state together in an otherwise empty five-dimensional spacetime.
The pair still cannot reach full equilibrium. That would require their rotations to match in both planes, and Armas found that is not possible while keeping a regular Black Saturn shape.
The two objects also affect each other. Spinning black holes drag the surrounding spacetime along, a phenomenon called frame dragging. Because of it, the ring can make the central black hole’s horizon rotate in a plane where that black hole has no angular momentum of its own.
There is no evidence that Black Saturns exist, or that our universe has the extra spatial dimension they would need. The result is a piece of theory, not an observation, and it will not change anything in daily life.
Its value is as a tool for physicists. Solutions like this give them a way to explore what general relativity allows, test earlier predictions in new ways and study how gravity behaves under conditions very different from those we observe. According to ScienceAlert, the work also lays groundwork for future research on how light and matter behave around such configurations, and on the geometry of spacetime inside their event horizons.
Around Prague, based on reporting by ScienceAlert