Lucy Letby’s lawyer says England’s Court of Appeal must urgently review her convictions after the Guardian reported that a key prosecution expert witness was barred from treating patients while her trial was still under way. The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), which prosecutes criminal cases in England and Wales, says it met its disclosure obligations.
The dispute centers on Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a pediatric endocrinologist whose opinion that two babies were poisoned with insulin was considered crucial to Letby’s convictions for attempted murder, the Guardian said. Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others and was sentenced to 15 whole-life terms. Court of Appeal judges turned down her applications to appeal.
The Guardian reported this week that Hindmarsh’s employer, University College London hospitals trust (UCLH), barred him from clinical practice in March 2023 while the trial at Manchester Crown Court continued. A UCLH medical director, Dr Tim Hodgson, wrote to the General Medical Council (GMC), the doctors’ regulator, that the trust could not accept the level of risk Hindmarsh appeared to pose to children, even under close supervision. Hodgson cited two cases in which he said Hindmarsh had advised child patients to stop taking insulin.
On April 21, 2023, a medical practitioners tribunal declined to suspend Hindmarsh but ordered that he be directly supervised in his clinical work. The Guardian said that appears to have had no practical effect because UCLH had already barred him from treating patients.
The prosecution’s lead barrister, Nick Johnson KC, described Hindmarsh to the jury on Feb. 23, 2023, as “the pre-eminent expert” in the narrow field of insulin. The Guardian said the jury was never told of the restriction, of the GMC investigation, or that his contract at Great Ormond Street hospital had been terminated in July 2022.
Mark McDonald, who has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, the miscarriages of justice watchdog, to refer the convictions back to the Court of Appeal, said the failure to disclose material information about Hindmarsh raises fundamental questions. He maintains that Letby is innocent. McDonald asked whether police knew and how the information stayed undisclosed. “We need answers,” he said.
Two senior lawyers told the Guardian that serious concerns about an expert’s professional abilities, combined with non-disclosure to the defense, could be grounds for appeal. Since the convictions, dozens of leading medical and scientific experts have contributed to reports submitted with the review application, arguing that the prosecution’s medical case, including Hindmarsh’s evidence, was wrong.
The CPS said it was never given information about the March and April 2023 developments, according to the Guardian. BBC News separately reported that police and prosecutors knew Hindmarsh was under GMC investigation when he testified, and that the CPS learned of it shortly before his second court appearance in February 2023. The Guardian reported that the CPS told the defense it would oppose telling the jury because the investigation had not concluded.
The CPS told the BBC it had met all its disclosure obligations, that the defense raised no objections about expert evidence and that regulatory investigations are separate from criminal proceedings. It added that an investigation does not determine whether evidence is admissible or reliable. According to the Guardian, Letby’s defense team did not apply to put the information before the jury because of the CPS’s opposition.
A representative of Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian’s questions. Cheshire police, who instructed him, declined to comment. The GMC investigation never concluded: GMC records show Hindmarsh relinquished his registration in November 2024 through voluntary erasure.
Criminal procedure rules require expert witnesses to tell the party instructing them about anything, including disciplinary proceedings, that might reasonably undermine their opinion or credibility. The BBC reported that CPS guidance from 2022 says such information may render past convictions unsafe. The BBC has asked the CPS whether it plans to refer the use of Hindmarsh in the Letby prosecution to its director of legal services and had received no response.
Around Prague, based on reporting by The Guardian, BBC News