U.S. By

What the Appeals Court Ruling Means for 20,000 Disputed California Ballots

A federal appeals court on Friday refused to let the Justice Department set aside mail ballots tied to more than 20,000 California voters the Trump administration suspects are noncitizens, CBS News, NBC News and Axios reported. The ruling leaves California’s election procedures in place days before Tuesday’s midterms.

What did the court decide?

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 against the Justice Department’s request for an injunction while its appeal proceeds. Judges Mark Bennett and Gabriel Sanchez, in an unsigned decision, said the department had not met its burden. Judge Patrick Bumatay dissented.

NBC reported that this was the second time in a week the panel had turned down an administration request to intervene in the case.

Why did the judges say no?

The majority said there is no workable way to identify and separate the ballots of specific people without potentially catastrophic effects on the whole system. It wrote that the relief the administration wants is “simple only in the abstract.” The judges also warned of a risk of disenfranchising eligible voters and jeopardizing the entire tabulation process.

The panel relied on findings by U.S. District Judge David Carter, who ruled Wednesday that the request violates longstanding principles giving states control of their elections. NBC reported that Carter doubted the administration’s methods and said the Justice Department’s process was not credible. He noted that the administration made similar claims in Nevada, where it first alleged 15,903 registered voters were noncitizens, later cut that to 6,218 and then to 185. Nevada officials later confirmed all 185 were citizens, the judge wrote.

What does the administration claim?

The administration alleges California sent ballots to about 20,000 people who may not be U.S. citizens and wants them set aside until citizenship can be verified. California officials say the list is highly unreliable and probably includes many citizens. According to CBS, federal prosecutors argue that counting votes from noncitizens would dilute citizens’ voices.

In his dissent, Bumatay called the government’s proposed remedy “modest” and said the federal government and states can work together. He wrote that California decided long ago that noncitizens cannot vote and that the government only seeks to safeguard that decision.

What other legal fights are under way?

CBS reported that a federal judge in Washington on Friday ordered the administration to share the disputed list of names with lawyers for the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights and the UCLA Voting Rights Project. It would be the first time a nongovernment group can evaluate the list.

A coalition of unions, including the A.F.L.-C.I.O. and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, also asked a federal judge to temporarily block the Justice Department from demanding that local officials stop counting ballots and from threatening criminal prosecution of officials who do not comply.

Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, has warned that election officials who knowingly process a noncitizen’s ballot face legal jeopardy. The Associated Press obtained subpoenas to Los Angeles County election officials, and at least three have been asked to appear before a grand jury on Nov. 4, the day after the election. CBS noted it is unclear whether the department plans criminal charges, and that it does not typically subpoena people it regards as targets of a criminal investigation.

Why does it matter?

For California voters, the ruling means ballots already cast are not being pulled aside. Millions of people in the state have already voted, and CBS reported that hundreds of thousands of ballots have been processed. Election officials say processed votes are anonymized and cannot be matched back to the voters who sent them, which the courts cited as a reason segregating specific ballots is not feasible.

NAACP general counsel Kristen Clarke, whose organization helped defend the case, said the decision shows elections must be governed by facts and law. Axios described the ruling as a major setback for a Justice Department it said has pressed unsubstantiated claims of widespread voter fraud in California.

What happens next?

The Justice Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment, including on whether it will seek emergency relief from the Supreme Court, NBC reported. The midterm election is Tuesday, and the union request, the data-sharing order and the grand jury appearances on Nov. 4 are still ahead.

Around Prague, based on reporting by CBS News, NBC News, Axios

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Democrats Lock In a 56-Seat Senate Majority After Alaska Race Ends
Democrats will hold 56 seats in the Senate when the new Congress convenes next year, their largest majority in nearly two decades, the Guardian reported. The tally became official on Tuesday, when the
Qpancy Children's Pajama Sets Recalled Over Burn Risk
Qpancy is recalling about 1,309 children's pajama sets sold on Amazon.com because they violate mandatory U.S. safety standards for children's sleepwear, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission ann
Michael LoSapio, Trump’s CISA Pick, Declines to Call Jan. 6 an Attack
Michael LoSapio, President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, told senators Thursday that he does not consider the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capi
CHE-US Magnetic Robot Toys Recall: Magnets Can Come Loose From Figures
CHE-US is recalling its magnetic robot-shaped stick figure toys in the United States because small, high-powered magnets can come out of them and be swallowed by children, the U.S. Consumer Product Sa
Patrick Stewart’s Death Certificate Names Cardiac Arrest and Lewy Body Disorder
Patrick Stewart’s death certificate lists cardiopulmonary arrest and a neurocognitive disorder with Lewy body as his cause of death, according to documents obtained by TMZ and relayed by The Independe
Johnson Level and CLC Tool Recall: 229,430 Units Lack Battery Safeguards
Hultafors Group North America is recalling about 229,430 trade tools in the United States because their button cell batteries can be reached easily by children, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commis

Related news

Democrats will hold 56 seats in the Senate when the new Congress convenes next year, their largest majority in nearly two decades, the Guardian reported. The tally became official on Tuesday, when the long ballot count in Alaska ended with
Qpancy is recalling about 1,309 children's pajama sets sold on Amazon.com because they violate mandatory U.S. safety standards for children's sleepwear, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission announced on Nov. 19. The agency said the s
Michael LoSapio, President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, told senators Thursday that he does not consider the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol an attack. He also refused to say wh
CHE-US is recalling its magnetic robot-shaped stick figure toys in the United States because small, high-powered magnets can come out of them and be swallowed by children, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) said in a notice
Patrick Stewart’s death certificate lists cardiopulmonary arrest and a neurocognitive disorder with Lewy body as his cause of death, according to documents obtained by TMZ and relayed by The Independent, E! News and the Los Angeles Times. S
Hultafors Group North America is recalling about 229,430 trade tools in the United States because their button cell batteries can be reached easily by children, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) said in a notice dated Nov.
President Donald Trump announced Thursday that he has pardoned Pete Rose, baseball's career hits leader, more than two years after Rose's death, according to ABC News, NBC News and Fox News. Rose died in 2024 at age 83. Trump made the annou
Fiona, the Cincinnati Zoo hippo whose story of surviving a premature birth made her one of America's best-known zoo animals, has died. The Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden announced the news Thursday, saying she did not recover after s
The Dow lost 1,101 points and closed below 50,000, and the S&P 500 fell for a sixth straight day. Fed rate-hike fears, money rotating into Anthropic and a short report on AMD drove the sell-off. Bitcoin touched about $61,700.
The leaders of the United States, China and Russia held an unprecedented three-way summit in the Chinese tech hub of Shenzhen on Thursday, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) gathering. President Donald Trump, C
JPMorgan Chase, Visa and Mastercard said Thursday that cyberattacks on outside vendors exposed some customer data, with Chase saying the attackers reached marketing data such as names and email addresses. All three companies said payment de
The U.S. Army plans to detonate about 5 tons of lead azide, a chemical used to set off munitions, at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant on Friday. Officials are asking residents of the nearby town of Middletown to leave for part of the day, acc