World By

Joanne Young Case: Why Campaigners Want Third-Party Consent Ruled Out in Rape Trials

The family of Joanne Young, a woman from Swindon, England, who was drugged and raped by men her husband invited to their home, is leading calls for the government to change the law so that defendants cannot claim a third party gave consent. The calls came after four men were found guilty on Thursday of sexual offences against her, the BBC reported. Warning: this story discusses sexual violence and abuse.

Prosecutors said the trial was the first of its kind in England.

What the case was about

According to the BBC, Philip Young drugged and abused his wife over a period of 13 years. He used websites and apps to invite men to their home in Swindon without her knowledge. The prosecution told the court that the four men, who did not know each other, never sought Joanne Young's consent before having sex with her.

The defendants said they had been tricked by Philip Young and believed she was agreeing. That claim is what has prompted the push for reform, because campaigners argue that someone else's say-so should never count as a defense.

What campaigners and officials are saying

Speaking outside Winchester Crown Court after the trial, Joanne Young, who has waived her right to anonymity, said no one should be able to give consent on another person's behalf. She urged the government to treat the issue as a priority so women are better protected in future.

Her daughter, Alex Young, backed the call in a LinkedIn post. She said it has been 23 years since the law was last updated and asked why it has not kept pace with changes in society and crime. She wrote that it is unacceptable that a partner's consent can be raised as an argument in court.

The Sexual Offences Act 2003 says a person consents if they agree by choice and have the freedom and capacity to make that choice. Professor Miranda Horvath, director of the Institute for Social Justice and Crime at the University of Suffolk, told the BBC that a person who has been drugged and is unconscious cannot consent, and that nobody can consent for someone else. She said technology is changing quickly and the legislation should be reviewed for improvements. She also called for suspect-focused investigations, better resourcing and training for professionals, and for platforms and tech firms that spread this material to be held to account.

Jess Phillips, a former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, told LBC she did not believe this would be the last such case unless changes are made. She said the men were able to find one another on websites that anyone can open, and that the state must make sure online safety laws are strong enough to stop it. Phillips said there is absolutely a case for making it an offense to advertise another person for sex online, and that every website named in the case should be asked to guarantee this is not happening now.

Dame Nicole Jacobs, the Domestic Abuse Commissioner, called the case a turning point. She said drug-facilitated sexual abuse should be recognized as a form of domestic abuse, not treated as an isolated incident.

Another survivor speaks about the websites

Laura Bishop, from Bristol, has also waived her anonymity. Her ex-husband received a 14-year prison sentence for drugging and raping her and inviting other men to abuse her. Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, she said the effects will stay with her for life. She said the sites used to advertise her are still active and, she said, are known by police not to supply evidence and forensic material when asked. She asked why they remain available. Bishop, who holds a PhD in cyber crime, works with MPs and charities on digital safety rules.

Why it matters

The debate centers on whether the current definition of consent is enough when a defendant says he was misled by someone else. Campaigners say it is not, and want the government to close off third-party consent as a defense in cases like this one. Debbie Beadle, chief executive of the Wiltshire domestic abuse charity Fear Free, said six in seven rapes of women are carried out by someone they know, which she said adds a barrier to coming forward. She hopes Joanne Young's decision to speak publicly will encourage other victims to do the same.

Around Prague, based on reporting by BBC News

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Anthropic IPO: What the Nasdaq Debut Means for Investors and Pension Funds
Anthropic began trading on the Nasdaq on Thursday, opening at $111.50 a share in what Fox Business called a record-setting initial public offering. The stock trades under the ticker ANT, and for the f
Daraxonrasib Pancreatic Cancer Pill: What the Early Trial Results Show
A once-daily pill taken alongside chemotherapy left tumors undetectable on scans in about one in 12 patients with advanced pancreatic cancer, according to early trial results reported by the BBC, LBC
Toyota Recalls 314,029 Older Toyota and Lexus Vehicles Over Takata Airbag Risk
Toyota is recalling 314,029 Toyota and Lexus vehicles in the United States because the front passenger airbag inflators, made by Takata, could rupture in a crash and throw metal fragments at people in
Democrats Lock In a 56-Seat Senate Majority After Alaska Race Ends
Democrats will hold 56 seats in the Senate when the new Congress convenes next year, their largest majority in nearly two decades, the Guardian reported. The tally became official on Tuesday, when the
Qpancy Children's Pajama Sets Recalled Over Burn Risk
Qpancy is recalling about 1,309 children's pajama sets sold on Amazon.com because they violate mandatory U.S. safety standards for children's sleepwear, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission ann
Michael LoSapio, Trump’s CISA Pick, Declines to Call Jan. 6 an Attack
Michael LoSapio, President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, told senators Thursday that he does not consider the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capi

Related news

A childminder in Romford, England, has lost her registration after a one-year-old boy twice got out of her care, the second time running into the middle of a road before a bin man brought him back, Metro reported. The childminding agency th
The ruins of the Ulpia Library, one of the great text repositories of the ancient world, are reopening to the public in Rome this week after a year of restoration. Visitors will be admitted only on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays at first, i
Britax Römer has recalled specified batches of its Baby Safe Pro infant carrier in the United Kingdom because the harness buckle may release or break when the carrier is installed on its base in the reclined position, according to the Offic
Police in London can now photograph a suspect on a smartphone, without that person's consent, and check the image against a database of around one million custody images. Metro reported that the Metropolitan Police, often called Scotland Ya
Britain and the European Union are expected to agree a youth mobility scheme at a summit in Brussels on Friday that would let up to 100,000 young people from the EU travel, work and study in the UK each year, the BBC reported. The same numb
El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele officially launched his bid for a third term on Thursday night, submitting his candidacy paperwork to the country’s Supreme Electoral Tribunal ahead of that day’s registration deadline, according to the
British and European negotiators were closing in on a package of agreements late Thursday ahead of a summit in Brussels on Friday. The deal could ease food trade between the United Kingdom and the European Union and let young people live an
Lucy Letby’s lawyer says England’s Court of Appeal must urgently review her convictions after the Guardian reported that a key prosecution expert witness was barred from treating patients while her trial was still under way. The Crown Prose
Saudi authorities said a Houthi attack damaged multiple floors of the tallest skyscraper in Riyadh on Thursday. The tower houses the headquarters of the Saudi Public Investment Fund, according to Fox News, which cited Reuters. Saudi Civil D
The campaign group Republic, which calls for the abolition of the monarchy, says it has handed police and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) a tranche of documents about Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, the Evening Standard reported. The group
A Cold Weather Payment is £25 for each 7-day period of very cold weather between 1 November 2026 and 31 March 2027, according to GOV.UK. Eligible people get it automatically and do not need to apply. When is a Cold Weather Payment triggered
A former senior Royal Canadian Mounted Police officer in British Columbia has received a conditional discharge for assaulting a teenager at a recreation centre in Abbotsford, CBC News reported. David Teboul, 52, was the B.C. RCMP's assistan