The International Court of Justice ruled on Thursday that Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya minority in 2017, DW and the Associated Press reported. It is the first time the court has found a state responsible for genocide. Myanmar's government dismissed the judgment on Friday as “unfair.”
The court ordered Myanmar to prevent a repeat of the crimes, allow displaced Rohingya to return, prosecute those responsible and compensate victims. Whether any of that happens is far from clear.
Myanmar argued throughout the case that its actions in Rakhine State were legitimate counterinsurgency operations against an armed group, the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army. The court rejected that. Court President Yuji Iwasawa said casualties and damage went far beyond what military necessity could justify, DW reported. He listed executions of Rohingya men and boys, widespread sexual violence, the targeting of children and the methodical burning of villages.
The court ordered Myanmar to allow a safe, voluntary and dignified return of those who fled, to investigate and prosecute those responsible, and to return or replace stolen property. DW reported that Myanmar must show within two years that it is compensating victims for what cannot be returned. ABC News reported that the compensation amount will be decided in later proceedings.
A government spokeswoman told reporters in Naypyitaw that Myanmar would state its position after reviewing the court documents, according to ABC News. She also questioned the court's authority to impose conditions and pointed to a declaration by the leaders of the United States, Russia and China, who said international judicial bodies must not abuse their jurisdiction.
China's foreign ministry spokesperson, Guo Jiakun, said such rulings are not conducive to resolving disputes, Al Jazeera reported. He added that China stood ready to play a constructive role in the return of displaced people from Rakhine State.
Rohingya activists welcomed the judgment. Rohingya activist Wai Wai Nu said it validated decades of persecution, DW reported. Myanmar's shadow National Unity Government also welcomed the ruling, while stressing that the military's ongoing violence against civilians must end.
For the Rohingya, the ruling is a formal legal recognition of what happened to them. For the wider world, it sets a precedent: Michael Becker, an international human rights law professor at Trinity College Dublin, told DW it shows that proving genocidal intent is not impossible.
Turning the orders into reality is a separate matter. DW reported that the same leaders accused of the crimes remain in power; Min Aung Hlaing, the former military chief, is now president. Much of the country, including Rakhine State, is in a civil war, and the Arakan Army, which controls most of Rakhine, is widely accused of persecuting the Rohingya as well.
Enforcement falls to the U.N. Security Council, where China and Russia would almost certainly veto punitive measures, said Richard Horsey of the International Crisis Group. He told DW that pressure is more likely to come from governments and the General Assembly. The U.K. said it was expelling Myanmar's defense attache in London and would call for a Security Council session on the decision.
Malaysia said on Friday it plans to resettle 10,000 Rohingya migrants in Turkiye, Al Jazeera reported. According to the United Nations, Rohingya make up two-thirds of the 190,000 Myanmar refugees and asylum seekers in Malaysia.
Around Prague, based on reporting by DW, Al Jazeera, ABC News