World By

Tusk Defends Move on Tribunal as Law and Justice Calls It a Coup

Poland's government has defended the suspension of the Constitutional Tribunal's president and the police presence at the court, while the opposition Law and Justice party (PiS) calls the moves a coup. Prime Minister Donald Tusk said on X on Friday that restoring the rule of law is the government's duty, according to Devdiscourse.

Justice Minister Waldemar Zurek also told reporters he has asked for the immunities of tribunal president Bogdan Swieczkowski and his deputy to be lifted. His reason is that they failed to fulfill their duties by preventing judges from doing their work.

What the government says

Tusk described the process as hard. In his post, he said that after years of lawlessness under PiS the effort is difficult and at times painful, and that it calls for decisive action. He added: "There is no other way."

Zurek's request targets Swieczkowski and his deputy directly. The justice minister argues that the two officials blocked judges from carrying out their work. According to Devdiscourse, Swieczkowski was a deputy justice minister under PiS and has declined to let judges elected by the current parliamentary majority take up their duties.

What Law and Justice says

PiS politicians, including party leader Jaroslaw Kaczynski, said Tusk's government is carrying out a coup against the tribunal, Devdiscourse reported. The reports do not detail the legal arguments behind that claim.

President Karol Nawrocki, an ally of the former nationalist PiS-led government, turned back his plane en route to Senegal after police entered the court's premises, according to The Jerusalem Post. He said the president must be in Poland at a moment like this.

What led to the police action

Police said officers entered the tribunal's premises after incidents outside the court, including the throwing of dangerous objects at police. The tribunal said on its website that Swieczkowski had been suspended on Friday. The reports do not say who ordered the suspension.

The dispute behind the standoff

The Jerusalem Post described a long-running political dispute that has effectively paralyzed the tribunal. Earlier this year, Nawrocki refused to swear in three of the six judges nominated by parliament. Swieczkowski, meanwhile, declined to allow judges elected by the current parliamentary majority to assume their duties.

Each side's actions have therefore fed the other's complaints. The government and its allies point to the blocked judges. PiS politicians frame the government's response as an attack on the institution.

What's at stake for Poland's top court

The Constitutional Tribunal is Poland's top court, and the reports say the dispute has left it effectively paralyzed. For ordinary Poles, the immediate question is whether the court can function again, because a paralyzed tribunal cannot do its work.

The standoff is also a direct confrontation between the prime minister and the president. Nawrocki has cut short an overseas trip over the events at the court, and Tusk has said decisive action is needed. The two leaders come from opposing political camps.

What happens next

The next step is the request to lift the immunities of Swieczkowski and his deputy. Reports so far do not say how or when that request will be decided. Whether the suspended court president is replaced, and how the judges currently blocked from the bench are handled, also remain open. Nawrocki's return to Poland sets up further contact between the president and the government over the court.

Earlier on Around Prague: Poland: Police Enter Constitutional Tribunal, Court Chief Suspended, Nawrocki Turns Plane Around

Around Prague, based on reporting by The Jerusalem Post, Devdiscourse

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

Fiona the Hippo Has Died: What We Know About the Cincinnati Zoo's Final Days
Fiona, the Cincinnati Zoo hippo whose story of surviving a premature birth made her one of America's best-known zoo animals, has died. The Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden announced the news Thur
Why the Stock Market Fell Today: Dow Drops 1,100 Points, S&P 500 Logs Sixth Straight Loss, Bitcoin Hits July Low
The Dow lost 1,101 points and closed below 50,000, and the S&P 500 fell for a sixth straight day. Fed rate-hike fears, money rotating into Anthropic and a short report on AMD drove the sell-off. Bitco
Trump-Xi-Putin Summit in Shenzhen: What Was Agreed and What It Means for the World
The leaders of the United States, China and Russia held an unprecedented three-way summit in the Chinese tech hub of Shenzhen on Thursday, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (AP
Chase, Visa and Mastercard Customer Data Exposed in Vendor Hacks: What We Know
JPMorgan Chase, Visa and Mastercard said Thursday that cyberattacks on outside vendors exposed some customer data, with Chase saying the attackers reached marketing data such as names and email addres
What Iowa's Planned Lead Azide Blast Means for Residents Near an Army Plant
The U.S. Army plans to detonate about 5 tons of lead azide, a chemical used to set off munitions, at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant on Friday. Officials are asking residents of the nearby town of Midd
Begich Wins Alaska's Lone House Seat as Democrats Take Senate and Governor
Rep. Nick Begich, a Republican, won re-election to Alaska's only U.S. House seat after the state's ranked-choice tabulation, Fox News reported. The race was called at 9:27 p.m. ET on Wednesday, more t

Related news

The Office for Product Safety and Standards (OPSS) in the United Kingdom has published a product safety report on Fashion Slime Bottle, a children's toy found to contain more boron than the law allows. The regulator describes the hazard as
U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are in Berlin on Nov. 19 to meet Ukrainian and European officials, aiming to prepare the next round of multilateral talks on ending the war in Ukraine. NPR reported that the meeting comes as Russi
Some prisoners convicted of terrorism offenses in England and Wales could be freed early under the government’s plan to ease overcrowded jails, Metro reported. Officials dispute how many would qualify, and the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) says
Leaders from Ukraine’s main allies met in Berlin on Thursday and called on Russia to agree to an energy ceasefire for the length of the winter as a first step toward ending hostilities, according to DW. The “Coalition of the Willing” talks
A father from Pitsea, Essex, in England, has been jailed for 28 months for illegally possessing gunpowder after a court heard that conversations with an AI chatbot fed his fears about the collapse of society, BBC News reported. Ben Banham,
U.S. President Donald Trump unexpectedly joined a meeting of Ukraine’s European allies by phone on Thursday and sharply questioned why they keep spending billions on military support for Kyiv, according to Politico. The outlet cited four Eu
Slovak F-16 fighter jets have been scrambled on alert for the first time, the TASR agency reported on Thursday. The aircraft took off from Kuchyňa air base in western Slovakia and were refueled by a tanker aircraft during the mission, armed
The presidents of the United States, China and Russia held an unprecedented three-way summit in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday and issued a joint declaration on stable energy flows, nuclear risks and other issues, Al Jazeera and the Guardian
A public inquiry into the United Kingdom's response to Covid-19 has found that the country was left “effectively blind” to the spread of the virus in early 2020 because testing was not expanded fast enough, the Evening Standard reported. Th
A boat carrying about 100 migrants capsized and washed ashore near the village of Yenne, south of Dakar, early Wednesday, and many of those aboard remain unaccounted for. Reports of the death toll differ, and search operations were due to r
A man who inhaled nitrous oxide, commonly known as laughing gas, before a crash that killed a 19-year-old woman in Kent, England, has been sent to prison, Metro reported. Luciano Spirito, now 25, was sentenced at Maidstone Crown Court on No
A late-night fire at the ancestral home of Muhammad Yunus, Bangladesh’s former interim leader and a Nobel Peace Prize laureate, appears to have been set deliberately, police said. The blaze comes as unrest spreads across the country ahead o