An idea about evolution that has circulated for more than 50 years may rest on a measurement illusion. Researchers at the University of Bath analyzed what they describe as the largest collection of spontaneous genetic mutations assembled to date, in the bacterium E. coli and in baker’s yeast, and found no evidence that essential genes mutate less often than other genes, according to ScienceDaily.
The study was published in PLOS Biology. Its authors say earlier results that seemed to support the idea may have been misled by harmful mutations that natural selection removed before anyone could count them.
First proposed in 1972, the hypothesis holds that organisms may have evolved ways to lower the mutation rate in their most critical genes, such as those involved in copying DNA or running basic cell machinery. Genes where change could be useful, such as those that give bacteria resistance to antibiotics, might mutate more often, according to the hypothesis.
That would depart from the standard picture, in which mutations arise as a source of variation and natural selection then decides which variants spread. ScienceDaily noted that the debate has returned several times, including in 2023.
They give two reasons. First, mutations in any single gene are already rare. Lowering that rate further would bring only a tiny extra benefit, which makes it hard for natural selection to favor such a protective system.
Second, earlier measurements may have been skewed. Mutations in important genes are more likely to be harmful, so selection quickly removes them. Professor Laurence D. Hurst said this can make important genes look as if they have fewer mutations when some have simply vanished before they could be analyzed. He called these “ghost mutations.”
Dr. Sofia Radrizzani and Hurst used data from mutation accumulation studies, which are designed to record mutations while limiting the influence of natural selection. That let them look at genetic changes in E. coli and baker’s yeast without the usual strong filtering.
The team also ran three independent tests to check whether selection might still have distorted the data significantly. None showed evidence of substantial bias. Radrizzani called the dataset the largest and cleanest sample of mutations assembled to date.
To judge how important each gene is, the researchers used experiments in which individual genes were removed from organisms.
The analysis found no evidence that genes essential for survival mutate less frequently than other genes. Radrizzani said the claim that mutation is slower for important genes is a triumph of hype over substance, and added that the suggestion is old and is reinvented in various forms routinely.
The result supports the conventional view that mutations arise without regard to how important a gene is, and that natural selection does the sorting afterward. ScienceDaily gave Darwin’s finches as a familiar example: random mutations produce differences in beak size and shape, and birds with better-suited beaks are more likely to survive and reproduce when certain foods become more plentiful.
The finding also carries a caution for researchers. Looking only at the mutations that remain in a population can give a false impression of how stable a gene is, because damaging changes may already have been weeded out.
The study covers one bacterium and one yeast. The sources do not describe results for other organisms, so the findings apply to those two microbes.
Around Prague, based on reporting by ScienceDaily