News By

Constitutional Court Rejects Government's Bid to Remove Judge from Pavel's Lawsuit

Constitutional Court Rejects Government

The plenary session of the Czech Constitutional Court has rejected the government's request to remove rapporteur judge Pavel Šamal from the case concerning President Petr Pavel's jurisdictional dispute lawsuit. This was stated in the court's ruling, published on Thursday.

Šamal had been handling the case as rapporteur judge, and it was on his recommendation that the court issued an interim measure obliging the government to ensure the president's participation in the Ankara summit. The government insisted that the judge had committed a procedural violation by forwarding the president's lawsuit to the cabinet for a response too late.

The Government's Complaints

President Pavel filed the jurisdictional lawsuit on June 22. According to the government, Šamal did not send the document to the cabinet for a response until June 25 — even though he had already requested supporting materials from the prime minister on June 23, and the court had issued its interim ruling on June 24.

The government's submission stated: "Judge Pavel Šamal violated his duty to immediately forward the lawsuit to the other parties in the proceedings along with a request for their explanations, as well as the government's right to comment on the merits of the lawsuit, thereby violating its right to a fair trial." The cabinet acknowledged that the judge's actions may have been an unintentional oversight, but argued that the serious consequences of this error warranted his removal from the case.

The Court Sides with the Judge

The Constitutional Court's plenary session disagreed with these arguments. In the court's view, the government was effectively seeking the judge's recusal based solely on the timing of his notification — that is, purely on procedural grounds. "In no judicial proceeding in the Czech Republic can a judge be deemed biased solely on the basis of his procedural actions," the court's published opinion states.

The court emphasized that an objection of bias is not intended to allow parties to a case to have the legality of a judge's actions reviewed simply because they accuse him of partiality. When examining such an objection, the court does not assess the lawfulness of the procedure itself, but solely whether the judge can be considered impartial. The plenum ultimately concluded that Šamal is not a biased figure, and the case will remain under his jurisdiction.

Around Prague, based on reporting by novinky.cz

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More U.S. news

What the West Coast Storm Train Means for Thanksgiving Travel
A string of powerful storms is set to hit the West Coast starting Tuesday, and forecasters say the rain, wind, mountain snow and coastal flooding could disrupt Thanksgiving travel on highways and at m
House Democrats Clinch 258 Seats, Their Biggest Majority Since 1992
House Democrats have won at least 258 seats, their best general election result in decades, after Democrat Chuck Hubbard defeated Republican Rep. Virginia Foxx in North Carolina on Sunday, ABC News an
Trump vs. Schumer: Why the President Is Weighing In on Senate Democrats’ Leadership Race
President Donald Trump said Sunday that it would be very hard for him to work with Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., if Schumer continues to lead Senate Democrats next year. Fox News reported that Trump pos
Delta Atlanta Delays by the Numbers: Automation Glitch Hits Start of Thanksgiving Rush
A failure in Delta Air Lines' weight and balance automation system led to hundreds of flight delays at Atlanta's Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport on Sunday morning, according to Fox 5 Atlanta
What Trump's Contractor Order Means for Companies Facing Congress
Companies that do business with the federal government now have to tell the White House when Congress asks them for information about their work, under an executive order President Donald Trump signed
Amazon Black Friday 2026: When It Ends, Who Can Shop and Whether Prices Are Lower
Amazon's holiday sales are live. The company's Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday events started Nov. 19 and continue through Nov. 30, according to Mashable. Amazon said the events will bring millions

Related news

  • 29 September 2026, 21:20
  • News
Russian aircraft dropped a quarter-tonne bomb on a school building in Sumy, in northern Ukraine, on Tuesday afternoon, the head of the regional military administration, Serhii Kryvosheienko, said on his Telegram channel. Pupils in grades on
  • 29 September 2026, 20:50
  • News
Fresh footage from webcams near the Matterhorn shows that by late September the famous peak on the border between Switzerland and Italy has lost almost all of its snow cover. White patches remain only on the mountain's highest sections and
  • 29 September 2026, 20:20
  • News
On Tuesday morning in the Slovak village of Staškov, in the Čadca district, a student at the local school attacked classmates and teachers with a knife. According to police, 61-year-old teacher Božena Mariaková died of her injuries, another
  • 29 September 2026, 19:20
  • News
The Czech Motorists party (Motoristé sobě) posted a pre-election video on social media in which officials rise up against “pirate” and “green” bureaucrats demanding endless stamps and permits, ending with the figure of one such official — a
  • 29 September 2026, 18:50
  • News
The United Kingdom has offered nine European countries — Finland, Denmark, Estonia, Iceland, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden — protection under its national nuclear umbrella as part of the Joint Expeditionary Force (JE
  • 29 September 2026, 18:05
  • News
The brand's last factory in the regionShoemaker Bata is shutting down production at its factory in the Czech village of Dolní Němčí, Moravia — according to the company itself, this was the last operating Bata plant in all of Central Europe.
  • 29 September 2026, 17:35
  • News
The Trade Union of State Bodies and Organizations (OSSOO) has sharply criticized Prime Minister Andrej Babiš's government plan to cut a tenth of the staff at Czech state institutions. According to available information, even government mini
  • 29 September 2026, 16:05
  • News
The High Court in Olomouc has upheld a 12-year prison sentence for a man named Tomi, who in September last year stabbed a woman in the chest in the center of Brno after she rejected him in the women's restroom of one of the buildings. The b
  • 29 September 2026, 15:35
  • News
Czech national team defender Vladimír Coufal will not play against England on Tuesday at Eden Stadium in Prague — coach Santi Denia left him out of the squad. Talk of the 34-year-old's absence started on Monday, when he skipped the open par
  • 29 September 2026, 15:05
  • News
Czechia remains one of the EU countries with the lowest flu vaccination rate — fewer than 10% of the population get a shot — even though the annual epidemics cost the economy billions of crowns and send serious cases, including fatalities a
  • 29 September 2026, 14:20
  • News
Petra Wünschová, a Czech psychologist, art therapist and founder of Prague's Locika centre — the first organization in Czechia to systematically help children who have survived domestic violence and abuse — died on 28 September 2026 at the
  • 29 September 2026, 13:50
  • News
Czech human rights organizations, including Amnesty International and Prague Pride, have demanded that Prime Minister Andrej Babiš reverse the appointment of three new members to the government's Human Rights Council — Kříž, Black and Kucha