Scientists now have two possible explanations for a puzzling discovery on Mars: a field of rocks made of nearly pure elemental sulfur. NASA's Curiosity rover first found them in 2024, according to ScienceAlert, and two studies published this summer propose how they might have formed.
Neither study claims to have settled the question, and neither points to evidence of life on Mars.
In 2024, Curiosity, which weighs 899 kilograms (1,982 pounds), rolled over an unremarkable rock in the Gediz Vallis Channel in Gale Crater. The rock cracked open, revealing pale yellow crystals that looked like pure sulfur. It was the first time elemental sulfur had been identified on Mars, although sulfates, which are salts that contain sulfur and oxygen, are fairly common there.
More rocks of the same kind were scattered around. Curiosity project scientist Ashwin Vasavada of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory compared finding a field of such stones to finding an oasis in the desert.
Sulfate minerals form when water carrying dissolved minerals evaporates, and they help scientists trace Mars' water history. Pure sulfur is different. On Earth, large deposits are often linked to volcanic or hydrothermal activity, but there was no sign of the high temperatures that would be needed in Gediz Vallis.
A team led by planetary scientist Scott VanBommel of Washington University in St. Louis reported its findings in the journal Science in June 2026. The researchers examined the rover's images and chemical analyses and confirmed that the sulfur was spread across an area of about 2,100 square meters and was remarkably pure.
The way the rock broke under only part of Curiosity's weight points to fragile material. On Mars, the rover weighs about as much as a 341-kilogram object does on Earth. The team argues that fragile rocks like these would be unlikely to survive transport, so they most likely formed where they were found.
One possibility the researchers suggest is that ancient volcanic activity released sulfur-bearing gases, which became trapped underground, perhaps inside cage-like ice structures called clathrates. As erosion carved out Gediz Vallis, pressure on the buried gases dropped and they escaped. Chemical reactions among them could then have produced pure sulfur without high temperatures. Based on the geological setting, the team estimates the deposit formed between 3.1 and 2.8 billion years ago.
Geochemist Jeff Berger of NASA's Johnson Space Center, who co-led the study, said it is hard to grasp how long the rocks sat there with almost no chemical change.
In a separate paper published in Geophysical Research Letters in July 2026, atmospheric scientist Jiawei Wang of Cornell University led experiments to see whether a chemical reaction in water could make pure sulfur without high heat or living organisms.
The team mixed dissolved sulfide with chlorate, a compound of chlorine and oxygen that may have existed on ancient Mars, in acidic water at room temperature. The reaction produced tiny yellow crystals of elemental sulfur. The amount of chlorate mattered: lower concentrations favored pure sulfur, while higher ones produced more sulfate.
The crystals were microscopic, far smaller than the chunks Curiosity found. The researchers suggest that similar reactions running over much longer periods could build larger deposits. They also noted that the hydrogen sulfide the reaction needs could have come from the same underground gas reservoirs proposed in the first study.
Sulfur is essential to all life, and many organisms take it up as sulfates to build two of the amino acids used in proteins. Because sulfates on Mars have been known for some time, the new finding adds nothing there.
Microbes can make elemental sulfur on Earth, but Wang's experiments show that living organisms are not needed to explain how it could form on Mars. No conclusive signs of life have been found on the planet.
What the discovery does offer is a clearer view of the ancient Martian environment: how gases moved underground, how water chemistry worked and how long some rocks can survive nearly unchanged.
Around Prague, based on reporting by ScienceAlert