Science & Space By

Giant Early Black Holes Leave Astronomers Unsure What Came First

Astronomers have long assumed that galaxies formed first and their central black holes grew later. Observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) are shaking that assumption, Live Science reported, and researchers it spoke with say the old order of events can no longer be taken for granted.

Nearly every large galaxy is thought to host a supermassive black hole at its center. The question of which came first, the black hole or the galaxy around it, now has no settled answer.

The numbers behind the puzzle

Why the standard picture is under strain

For decades, the prevailing view was that galaxies came first. Silk explained that dying massive stars leave black holes behind, and those can merge and feed until they reach millions of times the sun's mass.

JWST's look back at the early universe complicates that story. In a study published in the journal Nature, Maiolino and colleagues measured the mass of one black hole directly, in an object called Abell2744-QSO1, and found that it holds most of the object's mass. Maiolino told Live Science the findings show the old picture "cannot be the whole story."

Where such giants could come from

Maiolino outlined several possibilities and said more than one could be right. Some supermassive black holes may be ordinary stellar remnants that simply grew much faster than usual. Others may have been born big, formed when enormous gas clouds collapsed directly, which would give them a head start. A third idea is that primordial black holes, formed shortly after the Big Bang and before the first stars and galaxies, seeded the giants.

A cosmic tug of war

Black holes and galaxies also affect each other as they grow. According to Maiolino, a growing black hole can release enormous energy that heats or pushes out gas, which slows or halts star formation. The same process can also compress gas and potentially trigger new stars.

Silk said the balance differs by galaxy type. In giant elliptical galaxies, black holes weighing billions of suns can have violent histories that helped limit how much their hosts grew. In spiral galaxies like the Milky Way, he said, feedback from stars tends to dominate.

What it means for the question

For now, the chicken-and-egg puzzle is unresolved, and the scientists say the data to settle it does not yet exist. Silk said that if black holes outweigh their galaxies more and more the farther back astronomers look, that would strongly suggest black holes formed first. If stars dominate, it would point the other way.

Maiolino suggested the question itself may be too simple. Different black holes, in different environments and at different points in cosmic history, may have formed and evolved through different pathways, he said, so there may be no single sequence at all.

What happens next

Answering the question will take far more JWST observations, Silk said. A larger sample would show whether the oversize black holes seen so far are typical or unusual. Maiolino said astronomers are only beginning to explore a period of cosmic history that still holds many unanswered questions.

Around Prague, based on reporting by Live Science

Share: Telegram WhatsApp

More science news

Drones Swooping Through Whale Blows Let Scientists Read a Whole Whale Genome
Scientists have sequenced the entire genome of a whale using snot collected from its breath by small commercial drones, according to NPR. The team says it is the first time a whole whale genome has be
Lucy’s Relatives May Belong in Our Genus, a New Proposal Argues
A researcher in Australia is proposing a sweeping change to how scientists label our ancient relatives: put nearly all of them in the same genus as modern humans. According to ScienceDaily, which summ
A Roman Coffin at Westminster Abbey May Have Held a Saxon Abbot
A puzzle that has lingered for more than 150 years at Westminster Abbey may be close to an answer. According to ScienceDaily, new research suggests the skeleton found inside a Roman stone coffin at th
Do Vital Genes Mutate Less? Huge Bacteria and Yeast Study Says No
An idea about evolution that has circulated for more than 50 years may rest on a measurement illusion. Researchers at the University of Bath analyzed what they describe as the largest collection of sp
Winter Stargazing 2026-27: Three Supermoons, Geminids and Jupiter at Its Brightest
Winter brings long nights and a crowded sky. From December through February, stargazers can see three supermoons in a row, one of the year’s brightest meteor showers, Jupiter and Mars at their closest
Kids Who Logged More Screen Time Scored Better on Brain Tests as Teens
Children who spent more time on screens between about age 8 and age 16 tended to do better on thinking tests as teenagers, according to a Finnish study reported by ScienceAlert. The finding runs again

Related news

Scientists have sequenced the entire genome of a whale using snot collected from its breath by small commercial drones, according to NPR. The team says it is the first time a whole whale genome has been produced from this kind of sample. Th
A researcher in Australia is proposing a sweeping change to how scientists label our ancient relatives: put nearly all of them in the same genus as modern humans. According to ScienceDaily, which summarized the work from Monash University,
A puzzle that has lingered for more than 150 years at Westminster Abbey may be close to an answer. According to ScienceDaily, new research suggests the skeleton found inside a Roman stone coffin at the abbey was a medieval abbot, not the Ro
An idea about evolution that has circulated for more than 50 years may rest on a measurement illusion. Researchers at the University of Bath analyzed what they describe as the largest collection of spontaneous genetic mutations assembled to
Winter brings long nights and a crowded sky. From December through February, stargazers can see three supermoons in a row, one of the year’s brightest meteor showers, Jupiter and Mars at their closest, and a view of Saturn that is slowly im
Children who spent more time on screens between about age 8 and age 16 tended to do better on thinking tests as teenagers, according to a Finnish study reported by ScienceAlert. The finding runs against a common assumption that screens simp
The Pleiades star cluster, also called the Seven Sisters or Messier 45, can be seen from almost every part of the globe, according to EarthSky. It appears as a tiny, misty dipper of stars, and November is the month when it shines from dusk
A team of physicists says today’s best atomic clocks could be used to look for a strange quantum effect: a single clock experiencing more than one rate of time at the same moment. ScienceDaily, citing materials from Kyushu University,
A previously unknown camel with long, curved fangs once roamed the Great Plains of North America, and its bones have been sitting in museum collections for about a century. ScienceAlert reported that paleontologists have now named it Vampyr
For the first time, astronomers have watched two stars merge as it happened, according to Live Science. The pair, a supergiant and a star slightly smaller than the sun, orbited each other for thousands of years and then came together in jus
Layers of rock left behind by powerful ancient storms appear to grow thicker and more common on a cycle of roughly 405,000 years, according to a new paper reported by ScienceAlert. The authors suggest the rhythm may be tied to slow, periodi
A European-Japanese spacecraft is due to enter orbit around Mercury on Nov. 21, more than eight years after it left Earth, Space.com reported. The BepiColombo mission, run jointly by the European Space Agency (ESA) and the Japanese Aerospac