Why does the left side of your brain handle the right side of your body, and the other way around? Two neuroscientists at the University of Minnesota, Martin Wessendorf and Daniel Wang, have proposed a new evolutionary answer in the journal Frontiers in Neuroanatomy, according to ScienceAlert. Their idea is a theory built from existing research, not a new experiment, and it has yet to be tested.
The crossed arrangement is found in the brains of most vertebrates, humans included. Scientists have offered many explanations over the years, but ScienceAlert reports that the biological and evolutionary reasoning has not been settled.
Wessendorf and Wang say the crossing began with vision. They trace the earliest sign of this contralateral wiring to jawless fish more than 500 million years ago. In those animals, the eyes flipped incoming light, and the signals from each eye crossed to the opposite side of a brain region called the optic tectum. In mammals, the equivalent structure is called the superior colliculus.
The researchers argue that touch, vibration and pain senses then developed along the pattern the optic tectum had already set. In their words, the optic tectum’s crossed layout “biased the subsequent evolution of sensory and motor systems.”
The team did not run new experiments or dig up new fossils. According to ScienceAlert, they reviewed existing studies on all the major vertebrate groups, from amphibians to mammals, and compared how crossed pathways overlapped between species. The researchers wrote that, to their knowledge, nobody had tried to pull decades of lateralization studies together into one evolutionary history of crossed brain circuits.
The authors say evolution usually adapts what already exists rather than starting over. By the time true mammals appeared about 165 million years ago, their crossed sensory and motor systems had existed for almost 200 million years. When the more advanced cerebral cortex evolved, they argue, the most economical option was to connect to those pathways as they were, which left the right brain in charge of the left body.
Earlier proposals held that crossed wiring is somehow more efficient, or that the body of an ancient ancestor of all vertebrates became twisted. Wessendorf and Wang say those accounts do not cover the full evolutionary picture.
The question is basic science, and the study does not change medicine or daily life. It does offer researchers a concrete idea to check. ScienceAlert reports that the matter is not settled. Fossils of the roughly 500-million-year-old fish could provide further evidence, and mapping the neural wiring of animals not yet fully studied, including crocodiles and birds, could show where crossed organization arose.
The authors predict that in most or all vertebrate brains, the existing crossed design will prove more efficient than any plausible alternative where the same side of the brain controls the same side of the body. Whether that holds up will depend on the future studies the authors describe.
Around Prague, based on reporting by ScienceAlert