Uranus and Neptune have long been called “ice giants,” but a new paper proposes a way to test whether they hide large amounts of rock beneath their thick atmospheres. The idea hinges on a noble gas, argon, according to Universe Today, which described the work.
The paper was written by Olivier Mousis of the Southwest Research Institute and co-authors, and it appears in The Planetary Science Journal. It lays out a method for a future spacecraft rather than reporting a measurement made at the planets.
Astronomers have traditionally sorted the outer planets into two groups. Jupiter and Saturn are gas giants made mostly of hydrogen and helium. Uranus and Neptune are much smaller and packed with heavier elements, which is why they are called ice giants.
Universe Today reported that there is an ongoing debate over whether these distant worlds are in fact dominated by rock. No probe can drill into them, so researchers need indirect clues.
The clue is argon-40, an isotope of argon. It forms when potassium-40, an unstable form of a common element, decays. Most of that decay happens in rocks, and the argon-40 then seeps out into the atmosphere of its host planet. Universe Today said the gas makes up around 1% of the air on Earth.
The same process could take place inside Uranus and Neptune over billions of years. If so, measuring argon-40 in their atmospheres could serve as a rough gauge of how much rock lies below.
Rocks are not the only source of argon-40. Universe Today said plenty of it already existed in the cloud of gas and dust that formed the Sun and the planets. The young Uranus and Neptune could have trapped some of that leftover argon, which would then show up in their atmospheres without any help from rock.
According to the paper, how much they trapped depends on where the planets formed relative to the “argon ice line.” This is the region where temperatures of around 23-35 Kelvin cause argon to freeze or become locked inside water ice.
Researchers still disagree about where the ice giants formed. If they formed close to the Sun and later moved outward, they may have captured little argon, so most of what is in their air would come from rock. If they moved around early in their history, they probably captured a lot, and argon-40 alone would say little about a rocky interior.
Yes, at least in principle. Argon-36 is a lighter, non-radioactive form that does not come from decaying rock. Universe Today compared measuring it to having a control group. Because scientists have other estimates of the ratio of argon-40 to argon-36 in the early solar system, the amount of argon-36 would help show how much argon-40 the planets swallowed at birth. Whatever is left over could point to rock.
The question goes to the basic nature of two distant planets and to how they formed. It also affects how scientists plan to explore them. A mission called Uranus Orbiter and Probe is in active development and is planned to arrive at Uranus in the 2040s, Universe Today reported. That leaves time to refine what researchers expect to find.
For now the argument is theoretical. Only a spacecraft carrying instruments to sample the atmosphere could confirm whether these planets have a solid, rocky component.
Around Prague, based on reporting by Universe Today